Andrew Huberman on Sleep, Dreams, Fasting, Psychedelics and the Limits of the Human Mind

Lex Fridman Podcastwith Andrew Huberman· · Episode aired February 28, 2021· 13 min read
Listen to this summary

High-Level Overview

In his second appearance on the Lex Fridman Podcast, Stanford neuroscientist Andrew Huberman, who had just launched the Huberman Lab podcast, joins Lex for a wide-ranging, friendly conversation that starts with a simple question, why do humans need sleep, and ends up touching nearly everything about how the brain and body run. They cover the mechanics of sleepiness and body temperature, naps and non-sleep deep rest, how to get through Lex's upcoming 48-mile challenge with David Goggins, breathing while running, anger and testosterone, fasting and diet, what dreams do, psychedelics and neuroplasticity, blinking and computer vision, science communication, Clubhouse, and the kind of stress Elon Musk lives under.

The tone is warm and curious, with Huberman explaining mechanisms in detail and Lex responding with personal experiments from jiu-jitsu, fasting and endurance challenges. Both men are candid about their own habits and doubts, and there is a strong current of mutual admiration, since Huberman credits Lex with nudging him to start podcasting. The conversation flows from practical sleep science into performance and nutrition, then drifts into dreams, altered states and creativity before ending on podcasting, social media and the costs of an ambitious life.

Table of contents

The Discussion Explores:

  • The two forces behind sleepiness, adenosine and the 24-hour temperature rhythm, and how light shifts the clock
  • Why sleep anxiety may do more harm than imperfect sleep, and why consistency may beat total hours
  • Naps, 90-minute ultradian cycles, non-sleep deep rest and self-hypnosis
  • Strategies for Lex's Goggins challenge, including fasting, breathing and managing irritability
  • Anger, love, testosterone, prolactin and the idea that effort can be made to feel good
  • Intermittent fasting, keto, salt and electrolytes, carbohydrates for sleep, and omega-3s
  • What slow-wave and REM dreams do, including emotional uncoupling, and the link between dreaming and psychedelics
  • Neuroplasticity, acetylcholine, eye blinks, science communication and the stress of building ambitious things

Deep Dive into Main Ideas

Why we get sleepy: adenosine, temperature and light

Huberman jokes that he wasn't consulted at the design phase, but says two mechanisms clearly converge to make us sleepy. The first is adenosine, which accumulates in the brain the longer we are awake and binds to receptors to create sleep pressure. The second is the circadian rhythm, a roughly 24-hour temperature oscillation that bottoms out around 3 or 4 a.m., rises through the morning, peaks in the late afternoon and falls again in the evening. You can see the two decouple if you stay up all night: you feel terrible around 3 or 4 a.m., yet more alert by your usual waking time even though adenosine is higher.

He explains that every cell has its own clock driven by genes, and that a master clock above the roof of the mouth, the suprachiasmatic nucleus, keeps them all synchronized by controlling body temperature, work he credits to Joe Takahashi. Lex is struck by temperature as a universal coordination signal for a distributed system. Huberman adds that humans do better on a diurnal schedule than a nocturnal one, with strictly nocturnal people faring worse on immune and metabolic measures, and speculates that predators that see well in the dark shaped these rhythms.

For sleep itself, body and brain temperature need to drop by about two to three degrees to transition into deep sleep, which is why many people like a cool room with a warm blanket, and why a rising temperature, which triggers cortisol release, helps wake you. He then describes the temperature minimum, about two hours before your natural wake time. Bright light in the hours before it delays your clock so you'll want to sleep and wake later, while bright light in the hours after it advances your clock. For him, waking at 6 a.m. with a minimum around 4 a.m., light at 5, 6 or 7 a.m. shifts him earlier.

Sleep anxiety, consistency and the eight-hour question

Lex says he performs fine on a messy mix of power naps and all-nighters, and that obsessing over perfect sleep stresses him more than the lost sleep itself. Huberman agrees and editorializes that the push to take sleep seriously has gone too far, creating anxiety that short sleep will cause dementia or wreck hormones. He points out that fatigue is also driven by effort-related epinephrine, which builds to a quit point, while dopamine, the molecule of pursuit and reward, resets our capacity for effort. Since epinephrine is made from dopamine, which comes from tyrosine, he argues that joy in what you are doing literally supplies chemistry for effort, and that there's nothing new-agey about it.

He also advises not trusting your thoughts near your temperature minimum when sleep deprived. He cites a Stanford colleague's finding that positive anticipation of the next day supports quality sleep even when sleep is short, and a study from Bob Stickgold's lab at Harvard, run by Emily Hoagland, in which consistency of total sleep duration mattered far more for organic chemistry exam performance than total duration. His view is that there's no evidence eight hours beats six for everyone, and that waking at the end of a 90-minute ultradian cycle, say after six hours, can beat waking mid-cycle after seven. He personally does better on six than seven and rarely sleeps eight hours unbroken.

On sleep debt he says "There's no IRS for sleep." Actually falling asleep during the day signals you aren't getting enough at night, while being tired without dozing off likely means something else is fatiguing you.

Naps, non-sleep deep rest and self-hypnosis

Both men love naps. Huberman recommends 20 or 30 minutes, which keeps most people out of REM sleep unless they're sleep deprived. Longer naps can drop you into REM, where space and time are uncoupled, which can leave you disoriented. A late-afternoon dip in energy is a good time for a nap of 90 minutes or less, or simply lying down with the legs elevated.

He describes what he calls NSDR, non-sleep deep rest: lying down and letting the system drop into deep calm, which can make it easier to fall asleep later and restore cognitive and motor function. He mentions a Danish study showing a 20-minute protocol reset dopamine in the basal ganglia to levels seen after a full night's sleep. He also recommends clinically tested self-hypnosis scripts from his colleague David Spiegel, which involve looking up, closing the eyes, a slow deep breath and imagining floating. He admits he once did one and woke an hour later with his hand still floating. Real hypnosis, he stresses, is self-hypnosis, not the stage act.

Preparing for 48 miles with David Goggins

Lex is about to run four miles every four hours for 48 hours with David Goggins. Huberman offers two approaches: the full-blitz option of not expecting to sleep at all, which he learned from Navy SEAL friends who say a short nap during Hell Week can be worse than staying up, or anchoring to ultradian cycles and sleeping in the gaps. Eating diverts blood to the gut and makes you sleepy, and fasting raises epinephrine and alertness. Lex says overeating was his biggest mistake the previous time. Huberman then reads advice he texted Goggins for: be organized, waste as little time as possible, eat, sleep and rehab quickly, prep meals and gear, and, in Goggins's words, take a special pill called S.I.U., which stands for suck it up.

Huberman warns that REM deprivation makes people irritable and even slightly psychotic, because REM is when emotion is uncoupled from the previous day's events. He jokes that he knows he's REM deprived when the word "the" looks misspelled and it makes him angry. His advice is to take an observer's view of your irritability, stay quiet when needed, and use humor, which resets dopamine. He dislikes the word hack: gratitude and genuine reward work because that's how the nervous system evolved, but you can't fake being grateful.

He also shares unpublished work on breathing during effort. Inhaling moves the diaphragm down, enlarges the heart slightly and speeds heart rate, while exhaling slows it, the basis of heart rate variability. If your heart is racing, lengthen your exhales, and if you're flagging, emphasize inhales. While running at a steady cadence, he suggests double inhales through the nose to reinflate the lungs' alveoli, then exhaling through the mouth to offload carbon dioxide. He credits James Nestor's book Breath and the Stanford book Jaws by Sandra Kahn and Paul Ehrlich for the case for nasal breathing, but says that at maximal effort you should drop technique and just breathe.

Get new Lex Fridman Podcast summaries by email

The GIST of every new Lex Fridman Podcast summary in your inbox, daily or weekly. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Anger, testosterone and making effort feel good

Lex expects Goggins to push his buttons, so they discuss anger. Huberman says the alertness of love and of anger look physiologically identical, though love comes with serotonin and dopamine that replenish. He admits some of his best work came from not wanting to be out-competed, and says anger is powerful if channeled. Lex found that constant anger during a 30-day push-up challenge was exhausting and prefers to get lost in the ritual of the work.

Huberman turns to hormones. Cholesterol can become either cortisol or testosterone, and he says the major effect of testosterone is to make effort feel good. Chronic anger and stress may divert more toward cortisol over time. Drawing on Duncan French's work on stress hormones, testosterone and dopamine, he concludes that enjoying yourself helps maintain testosterone, which makes effort feel good, and he calls that feeling in the process, not the reward at the end, the holy grail. He tells a moving story of a dying colleague who, minutes after applying an androgen cream, said he wanted to live into the new year and write 12 letters of recommendation, while stressing he is not suggesting people take androgens. He adds that the opposite of testosterone isn't estrogen but prolactin, which makes us quiescent.

Fasting, keto, salt and eating for sleep

Huberman separates science from anecdote. He cites Satchin Panda at the Salk Institute, author of The Circadian Code, whose work shows that restricting eating to a 4 to 10 hour window aligned with daylight improves metabolic markers and reduces liver disease and body fat in animals, and that mice eating the same food spread across the day got fat and sick. In humans adherence is key, and low-carb, protein-rich diets tend to reduce hunger. Fasting raises alertness to drive food-seeking, while tryptophan-rich foods and complex carbohydrates promote sleep. He eats in a six-to-eight-hour window, eats carbs such as oatmeal and rice, and prefers them at night for sleep. One meal a day makes him too sleepy because he eats so much.

Lex describes performing more precisely in jiu-jitsu while fasted. Huberman relays a SEAL friend's story of feeling amazing around day six or seven of a nine-day fast, and recounts getting psoriasis-like scalp problems when he did keto wrong. When Lex says bone broth makes him feel better while fasting, Huberman suggests it may be the salt: unless someone has hypertension, sodium, potassium and magnesium are essential for neurons, and jittery fasters often need salt water rather than sugar. He mentions studies finding at least 1,000 milligrams of EPA from fish oil can reduce depressive symptoms comparably to some SSRIs, and that he has bought Athletic Greens since around 2012 with no affiliation. They also discuss ethically raised meat from Belcampo and Lex's plan to try a vegan diet seriously.

Dreams, REM sleep and emotional uncoupling

Huberman describes Matt Wilson's work at MIT showing hippocampal place cells replay a maze route during sleep, something also seen in London taxi drivers. Replay links locations to emotional context so you remember where something important happened. Early-night slow-wave sleep dreams are vaguer, while growth hormone is released and muscles repair.

REM dreams, which dominate toward morning, happen with very little epinephrine and with paralysis, yet feel intensely emotional and full of theory of mind, the attribution of motives to others, a concept from Simon Baron-Cohen. REM is when we divorce emotion from experience and extract general rules, which he likens to self-induced trauma therapy. He compares it to EMDR and to ketamine used in emergency rooms after horrific events, and describes PTSD as a failure to uncouple emotion from intense experiences. Waking suddenly from REM can bring a surge of epinephrine or a moment of sleep paralysis.

He also explains an endurance question: "What causes us to stop an endurance event is usually not a physical barrier. It's almost always a purely mental barrier." A Janelia study made running animals believe their effort was futile, and they quit when epinephrine in the brainstem crossed a threshold, but kept going if given dopamine. Humans have an advantage because they can draw on the past and future, for example running in honor of someone who died.

Psychedelics, plasticity and wordless states

Referencing Lex's conversation with Matthew Johnson of Johns Hopkins, Huberman says there's a close relationship between hallucinogenic states and REM dreaming, a connection he first read about in Allan Hobson's work, including Dream Drugstore. Psychedelics open windows of plasticity, but he warns that people treat plasticity as the goal, when "plasticity is a state within which you can direct neurology." He cites a UC Davis paper in Nature on modified psychedelics that keep plasticity without hallucinations, and calls MDMA unusual because it raises both dopamine and serotonin, an unprecedented state whose use should be carefully considered. He quotes a physician friend: "better living through chemistry still requires better living." He imagines future therapy combining psychedelics with brain stimulation, transcranial magnetic stimulation or focused ultrasound.

On DMT, he says people describe it as a freight train through space and time, unlike LSD or psilocybin. He is fascinated by wordlessness, states such as jiu-jitsu, surfing, dance and sleep where the language brain shuts down, and argues phones keep us in words. On creativity he says "creativity is in the non-linearities, right? But productivity is in the implementation of linearities," and notes that rigid thinkers fear letting go while creative people fear imposing structure. He praises the Hopkins group as pioneers, quoting Terry Sejnowski that you can spot pioneers because they're the ones with the arrows in their backs.

Neuroplasticity, blinking and new tools for neuroscience

Huberman's favorite underused finding comes from Mike Merzenich and colleagues: acetylcholine released from the nucleus basalis during an event rapidly and permanently reorganizes the cortex, enabling adult plasticity and even single-trial learning. He thinks this could accelerate skill and language learning and help kids with dyslexia, mentions Eddie Chang's language work at UCSF, and notes a Nobel-winning colleague who chews Nicorette, while saying he is not recommending it and that safer, directed pharmacology is needed. He says neuroscience lacks conceptual leadership, predicts robotics and machine learning will reveal how the brain works, and notes that neurons multiplex, like retinal cells that change function at dusk.

Lex describes extracting blink and eye data from the Joe Rogan archive to study cognitive load. Huberman says blink rate rises with fatigue, blinks reset time perception, and meaningful signals require an individual baseline. He sees great promise in non-contact sensing of stress, such as changes in skin tone, and in studying two interacting people as one system, like fighters in a staring contest.

Podcasting, social media and the cost of ambition

Huberman says Lex inspired his podcast. His hardest choice was staying on one topic for several episodes, and he prepares 10 to 15 hours of passive listening and five or six of active work per episode, reading reviews, listening to lectures and mapping ideas on a whiteboard. They discuss science communication moving online, the intimacy of voice-only spaces like Discord and Clubhouse, the time sink of social media, and how easily reproduced content rarely expands us.

Lex closes by asking about Elon Musk's description of his life as stressful, and about his own fear of starting a company after receiving online hate for the first time. Huberman says Musk seems to get his dopamine from hard problems, like his bulldog Costello who is happiest chewing, and suggests Lex's answers may come in the nonverbal states of the Goggins challenge.


Conclusion

This is a sprawling but rewarding conversation that turns neuroscience into usable ideas. Sleepiness comes from adenosine plus a temperature clock you can steer with light; consistent sleep and a calm attitude toward imperfect nights may matter more than hitting eight hours; short naps and non-sleep deep rest can restore you; and enjoying effort changes the chemistry that lets you keep going. Huberman explains how REM dreaming strips emotion from memories, why psychedelics and plasticity need direction, and why the limits of endurance are mostly mental. Throughout, he and Lex model being scientists of their own bodies while respecting data, and listeners who want the details of any thread, from breathing on a run to the future of brain research, will find plenty worth hearing in full.


This is a summary of "#164 – Andrew Huberman: Sleep, Dreams, Creativity & the Limits of the Human Mind" from Lex Fridman Podcast, giving you the GIST so you can decide if you want the REST. Listen to the full episode.

Mentioned in this episode

Some of these are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Perfect Summary is paid a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Perfect Summary earns from qualifying purchases.

  • The Circadian Code · Satchin Panda(our summary)
    Huberman's recommended source on time-restricted eating research
  • Breath · James Nestor
    Cited for the popular case for nasal breathing
  • Jaws: The Story of a Hidden Epidemic · Sandra Kahn and Paul Ehrlich(our summary)
    Stanford book on why nasal breathing beats mouth breathing
  • The Dream Drugstore · Allan Hobson
    Explores similarities between psychedelic states and REM dreams
  • Eight Sleep · Eight Sleep
    Lex says temperature-controlled mattress was a game changer
  • Athletic Greens · Athletic Greens
    Huberman has bought it since 2012 for vitamins and minerals
Get new Lex Fridman Podcast summaries by email

The GIST of every new Lex Fridman Podcast summary in your inbox, daily or weekly. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Want the REST?

This is an independent summary. Listen to the full conversation from Lex Fridman Podcast.

Full episode

More from Lex Fridman Podcast