Insight | Capture every idea: the notebook habit behind prolific creators

September 28, 2026 · 23 min read

Taylor Swift capturing every idea, Adam Grant on notebooks and blind spots, and Rick Rubin's habit of noticing clues everywhere all point to writing ideas down the moment they appear. Ideas are cheap to lose and easy to keep, so a capture system pays for itself.

Listen to this insight

The Short Version

Across four conversations, the same practical rule keeps coming up: when an idea arrives, write it down right then, because it will not wait for you. Taylor Swift types every lyric idea "into this endless note pad on my phone" and later mines a year of those scraps to build songs [1]. Andrew Huberman carries a notebook because "if we don't write them down, they're gone" [2]. Adam Grant, talking with him, adds that ideas get better when you file them away and let them incubate [2], and that we are blind to more about ourselves than we think [2]. Rick Rubin says "there are clues everywhere" for anyone paying attention, and treats seed collecting as a phase of creative work that never stops [3][4]. Capturing an idea takes a few seconds and costs almost nothing, while losing a good one is permanent, so a simple capture system pays for itself quickly.

Table of contents

What They Said

Taylor Swift, through Mel Robbins: the endless note pad and the lyric library

Mel Robbins built an episode around six free habits of very successful people, and the second one is Taylor Swift's way of capturing ideas [1]. Robbins sets it up with Swift's output: The Tortured Poets Department arrived with 16 songs and three bonus tracks, then a surprise anthology of songs 17 through 31, and "All 31 songs debuted on the Billboard 100 and she took over the top 14 spots," which Robbins calls "the first time this had happened in Billboard history" [1]. Her question is how someone keeps producing at that volume.

The answer comes from a 2015 interview with singer-songwriter Ryan Adams, who asked Swift how she keeps all this information in one place [1]. Swift says: "When I'm like prewriting, which is what I'm always doing, like right now, like I'm not actively making an album. But if I get an idea that I feel like is a cool observation and it's a cool lyric thing, I just write it, I type it into this endless note pad on my phone" [1]. Two details stand out. First, she is "always prewriting, even when no album is under way, so capture is a constant background habit and not something saved for a writing session. Second, the bar for writing something down is low: a cool observation" or a "cool lyric thing" is enough [1].

The payoff is the second stage. When she wrote "Blank Space," Swift says, "I wrote the chorus and I was like, all right, I need to search through all my lyrics that I've thought of in the last year that have to do with like this over dramatic kind of looks kind of visual that I want to paint" [1]. She would "go through and cherry pick" lines, and "Those are things that I had thought of maybe, you know, any time throughout the year" [1]. So the note pad is not a diary. It is raw material, collected at random times and searched later by mood and theme when a song needs it.

Robbins draws three lessons. The first is about practice: "Anything that you want to be better at, make it a daily practice," and Swift, "even when she is not actively writing an album, she has a daily habit of capturing ideas in one place" [1]. The second is about forgetting. Robbins describes the familiar moment "where you have this great idea and you tell yourself I got to write that down, I got to remember that. And a minute later, you don't remember it at all" [1]. Swift's answer to that problem, in Robbins' words: "I take it out of my head and I make it real and I ground it in the real world by typing it into my phone" [1]. Because Swift does this, "she now has an ongoing library that she can access in the future," while without it the "epiphany that one day I was walking the dog" would simply be gone [1]. Robbins puts it bluntly: "If you try to hold on to all the amazing ideas that pop into your head, you're just going to forget them. They're going to come and they're going to go" [1].

The third lesson is about how it feels. Robbins argues that "When you make it a habit to put it in a notes app or a notebook, you are validating your ideas. You're making it a habit to be creative" [1]. In her wrap-up she goes further: "every time you do that, you are honoring your own wisdom. You are saying this idea and this insight is worthy of me remembering it" [1]. The format does not matter to her, whether it's "the notes app or this little notebook or the no card however your system is, just get it in the physical space" [1].

Chris Robbins: 30 years, one pocket notebook, about 50 filled

Robbins' most concrete example is her husband Chris. He carries "a tiny little notebook that can sit in the back pocket of a pair of khakis," which she guesses is "maybe it's like three and a half inches wide" [1]. "The man always has it on him." When he drives, it comes out of his pocket and sits "right in between us in his truck" [1]. Whenever he has an idea, "whether he's walking in the woods or he's sitting at a stop sign or he's cooking dinner," he writes it down, and he has done this for the whole 30 years they have been together: "He has probably 50 of these things if I come to think of it" [1].

The details matter for anyone designing a system. The notebook is small enough to carry everywhere, it is always within reach (even in the truck), and it gets used in ordinary moments, not only at a desk [1].

Mel Robbins' own honest struggle

Robbins admits she hasn't cracked it herself. "I don't know if it's the ADHD or the dyslexia or just complete disorganization," she says. "I have tried notebooks. I've tried those moleskin journals. Right now I'm working on a system where I'm using three by five note cards and they're all over the frickin place" [1]. She also saves things into organized folders on Instagram, but concludes: "I don't have a system yet" [1]. Her plan: "I guess I'm going to try the notes app just like Taylor Swift" [1]. This is useful because it shows the common way capture fails: not because people don't write ideas down, but because the notes end up scattered in too many places to search later, which is exactly what Swift's "one place" avoids [1].

Robbins also ties capture to another habit in the episode. Shigeru Miyamoto, creator of Super Mario and Zelda, wanders city streets and parks watching people and places, and neuroscientist Dr. Tali Sharot explains that the brain habituates to repeated routines, so new inputs spark new ideas: "Whatever kind of life you have, you can actually shake things up a little bit" [1]. Robbins then links the two habits: take "all those creative ideas that you're going to get from the habit of wandering around and you get them on paper or you get them on a notes app or you put them on a note card so you establish this library of ideas to come back to" [1]. Wandering produces the ideas; capture keeps them.

Andrew Huberman: grab everything, then filter

Huberman is the most consistent note-taker across the Huberman Lab conversations. In his talk with Adam Grant he describes thinking about projects all the time, even "walking to take out the recycle. I'll have ideas. And then I'll write them down. I constantly am writing things down" [2]. He then names the method: "I have a method of capture where I basically try and just grab everything and then filter out what's useful" [2]. That two-step split, capture everything and judge later, matches Swift's note pad and cherry-picking almost exactly [1][2].

He also knows when his ideas tend to arrive. People have ideas "in the shower or while running or while falling asleep," he says, but "my best idea has always come within the first hour after waking. That's why I carry a notebook around" [2]. He admits the habit has a cost, saying he often doesn't want to talk to anyone first thing in the morning, which "is problematic and I had to make adjustments" [2].

Later he holds up his notebook and pen and says he tries "not to take notes on my phone ever," explaining that with voice recognition "it's hard to go back to that in a systematic way for me" [2]. He points to research he says shows "you have a better memory for information when you take notes by hand than by keyboard" [2]. And he states the core problem in plain terms: "it is amazing how sometimes we will have ideas while running, walking, showering out and about. And then later try and recall those ideas. And if we don't write them down, they're gone" [2].

In his first conversation with Rick Rubin, Huberman credits the habit to Joe Strummer of the Clash, whom he calls one of his few heroes. He remembers Strummer saying "that if you have an idea You have to write it down," and "But if you wait it will be gone," and adds: "as a consequence I have a whole system that I used to try and capture ideas" [4]. In the Grant conversation the summary gives Strummer's version as ideas falling like rain that have to be caught [2]. Huberman also wrote another Strummer line, "no input no output," on his lab wall [4].

His methods vary across episodes. In the Grant conversation he mentions voice memos into his phone alongside his writing [2], and in the Rubin episode he says he prefers speaking ideas into voice memos and having a service like Rev turn them into transcripts, a trick he learned from neuroscientist Richard Axel [4]. The common thread is not the tool but the rule: nothing gets trusted to memory.

Adam Grant: file it away, let it incubate, and watch for blind spots

When Huberman asks Grant whether he has a capture process like his, Grant's answer is short: "A little bit. I do now" [2]. The notebook in that exchange is Huberman's, not Grant's. Grant keeps his to-do list and his "to-don't" list in "a word document on my computer," and says "that's where most of my good thinking and writing happens" [2]. His contribution to this insight is about what happens after an idea is captured, and about what we fail to see in ourselves.

Incubation. With doctoral student Jihae Shin, Grant studied procrastination and creativity. In a Korean company, people who procrastinated sometimes were rated by supervisors as more creative than those who rarely did, and in the lab a moderate amount of delay produced the most creative ideas [2]. Grant explains that pre-crastinators lock onto their first ideas, chronic procrastinators grab the easiest idea at the last minute, and people in the middle let ideas incubate in the back of their minds, and this only worked when people cared about the task [2]. He changed his own practice because of it: "Whereas an earlier version of me, like when I'd sit down to write a book, as soon as I had the book idea, I would start writing on day one. Now I have the idea. I file it away and I give myself at least a month before I began drafting. And I think it feels less productive, but it's far more creative" [2]. Elsewhere he puts it as "I will not commit to an idea until I've let it incubate for a few weeks" [2].

That is the reason a capture system matters beyond simply not forgetting. You can only file an idea away if it has been written somewhere you can find it again. Grant's month of incubation needs a record, and Swift's year of saved lyrics is the same idea over a longer time [1][2].

Ideas come at any time. Asked when he gets his ideas, Grant says it could be anytime, and that hosting a podcast gives him an excuse to learn from almost anyone, "that having that built-in mechanism for learning means ideas could, could come at any moment" [2]. He also describes how intrinsic motivation keeps the mind working off the clock: when you enjoy the work, "You're more likely to think about it when you're not doing the task and come up with great ideas" [2]. Both points mean ideas show up away from the desk, which is exactly when a pocket notebook or phone note is needed.

Blind spots. Grant calls the bias blind spot, the belief that you are not biased, the mother of all biases (from Emily Pronin's research), and says people with high cognitive ability are more prone to it [2]. We are also blind to our strengths. The reflected best-self exercise, developed by Jane Dutton, Laura Morgan Roberts and colleagues, asks 10 to 20 people for a specific story of you at your best and then looks for patterns [2]. Grant flipped it, writing stories to 100 people about times they were at their best, which he calls one of the best weeks of his life and which helped him see himself as a synthesizer of ideas [2]. He also urges thinking like a scientist, treating opinions as hypotheses waiting to be tested [2]. The sources don't say these exercises need a notebook, so treat the link as our reading: patterns in your thinking, in other people's stories about you and in your own untested hypotheses only become visible once they're written down and can be looked at side by side.

Rick Rubin: clues everywhere, dreams that come back, and seed collecting

Rubin approaches the same habit from a different place. For him creativity is felt, not reasoned out, "closer to magic than it is science" [3]. His central image is a dream: "When you wake up, you might remember part, but not the whole thing. Then if you start writing them down, they'll come back" [3]. They may not make sense, and "maybe someday in the future you'll be able to look back and understand what they mean, and maybe not" [3]. That is a strong case for writing ideas down before you understand them: the act of writing brings back more of the idea, and the meaning can come later.

Huberman frames Rubin's book with the image of ideas as a cloud: "If you look at it at one moment, you might think that it looks like one thing. But then you look at it a moment later, it could be quite a bit different. And if you look at an hour later, it very well could be gone" [3]. It's the same point as Robbins' walk with the dog [1], put more poetically.

Clues everywhere. Asked whether there are clues in everything, Rubin says: "Everywhere. Yes. I think there are clues everywhere. If we pay attention, We'll hear a phrase. We'll trigger a thought. We'll see something unexpected" [3]. He applies it to recommendations: "If someone recommends something to you, maybe it's a coincidence. If three people recommend the same thing to you, maybe it's not" [3]. And he adds: "I do believe the universe is on the side of creativity" [3]. In the longer conversation he says ideas will happen through you if you're paying attention, or through someone else if you're not [4], and describes the raw material of creative work as a conveyor belt of little gifts that you first have to notice before you can open one [3]. Noticing that three people recommended the same thing only works if you can remember the first two, which is where a written record helps.

Seed collecting never stops. Rubin divides creative work into four phases [3][4]. The first is seed collecting, an ongoing part of life with no deadlines: noticing anything that sparks interest [3]. His example is wondering whether a movie exists on some subject and, if not, whether one should be made [4]. Then comes experimentation, where like a gardener you plant and water seeds but can't make them grow; then crafting, where you shape and combine what grew; and last, completion, the final edit into a shareable version [3][4]. The phases overlap, and he is always collecting seeds [3]. He learned from writing his book that we're not required to treat the different phases of work in the same way [3]: deadlines hurt the early phases and can help the late ones [3][4].

His actual practice. Rubin wakes slowly, gets into the sun for about an hour, and usually walks the beach alone for an hour to 90 minutes, not looking at his phone but listening to lectures, podcasts or audiobooks [4]. Ideas go into notes on his phone [4]. His notes are mostly for himself: he learns things because they interest him, and they often find their way into projects later [4]. Like Swift's lyrics, the notes are gathered without a specific use in mind and pay off months later.

Feed the capture with new input. Rubin says novelty wakes us up, since if we saw a Hubble photo every day we'd become numb to it, and a whale surfacing or a bird flying into the house breaks us out of our trance [4]. He describes a painting exercise where students study a model in one room and paint from memory in another, capturing what stuck with them [4]. He also says everything he has made started with seeing or hearing something that showed him what he hadn't seen before [4]. This fits Sharot's point on the Robbins episode about habituation and new inputs [1] and Strummer's "no input no output" [4].

Capture is not stewing. Rubin gives a project total focus while he works on it, whether for 20 minutes or five hours, and then tries not to think about it at all when he leaves [3][4]. He believes the subconscious keeps working: "to stew over a problem is not the way to solve a problem. Think to hold the problems lightly" [3]. He is anxious at the start of every project, "Even though it has never not come, you know, it has come every time" [3]. This is relevant because capturing an idea is how you get it out of your head so you can stop holding it. Writing it down lets you let go, the way Rubin describes, without losing it.

Get new summaries by email

The GIST of every new summary in your inbox, daily or weekly. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Where They Agree, and Where They Don't

They agree ideas vanish fast. Robbins says an idea is gone "a minute later" [1]; Huberman says ideas you don't write down are "gone [2]; Strummer, as Huberman quotes him, says if you wait it will be gone [4]; and Huberman's cloud image in the Rubin talk has the idea gone" within the hour [3]. No source argues memory is reliable enough to skip writing.

They agree ideas show up away from the desk. Swift is "always prewriting even between albums [1]; Chris Robbins writes in the woods, at stop signs and while cooking [1]; Huberman gets his while walking to the recycling and in the first hour after waking [2]; Grant says ideas could come at any moment" [2]; Rubin gets them on beach walks, from a phrase or from a recommendation [3][4]. So the capture tool has to be on you, not in your office.

They agree capture and judgment are separate steps. Huberman grabs everything "and then filter out what's useful" [2]. Swift saves any "cool observation" and cherry-picks a year later [1]. Grant files an idea away and waits a month before drafting [2]. Rubin keeps seed collecting separate from experimenting, crafting and finishing [3][4]. Nobody recommends judging ideas at the moment they arrive.

They disagree on the tool. Swift uses her phone's notes app [1], and so does Rubin [4]. Chris Robbins uses a pocket notebook [1]. Huberman, in the Grant conversation, says he tries "not to take notes on my phone ever," because voice notes are hard to go back to systematically and handwriting may help memory [2], though he also mentions voice memos, and in the Rubin episode he says he prefers voice memos transcribed by a service [2][4]. Grant keeps his lists in a Word document on his computer [2]. Mel Robbins has tried Moleskines, note cards and Instagram folders and has settled on none [1]. The reason each side holds its view is practical: the phone is always with you and searchable (Swift's search through a year of lyrics depends on that) [1], while paper is quick to use, avoids the phone's distractions, and, by Huberman's account, is better for memory [2]. None of the sources treat one tool as correct; each person uses whatever they'll actually carry and go back to.

They put different weight on what happens next. For Swift and Robbins, the value is the library itself: a store you can search when you need material [1]. For Grant, the value lies in the waiting time the capture makes possible, since incubation produces better ideas than acting on the first one [2]. For Rubin, capture is part of a way of paying attention, where the point is to notice clues and hold them lightly, not to build a database [3][4]. These don't conflict, but they do suggest different habits: regular searching (Swift), a deliberate waiting period (Grant), or relaxed, constant noticing (Rubin).

A caution about copying anyone's system. Rubin warns against assuming your method is best because it worked before: "it's just a way, and it's just a way that happened to work that time" [3]. Advice from experienced people "is not based on your life or your experience, it's based on their life and their experience" [3]. Robbins' own struggle, trying several systems and not yet finding one [1], shows the same thing. What all the sources share is the habit. The exact tool is personal.

Why It Works

Memory drops ideas quickly and without warning. The sources describe this more from experience than from studies: the idea that's gone "a minute later" [1], the cloud that "very well could be gone" in an hour [3], the dream you only half remember on waking [3]. Rubin adds that writing a dream down brings more of it back [3], so capture doesn't only save an idea but can bring back more of it.

A saved idea gets reused. Swift's "Blank Space" process shows the mechanism: lines thought of "any time throughout the year" become usable when a chorus calls for that mood [1]. Robbins calls this "an ongoing library that she can access in the future" [1]. Rubin's notes, gathered out of interest, often find their way into later projects [4].

Incubation needs a parking place. Grant's research with Jihae Shin found that moderate delay beat both rushing and last-minute work for creativity, because ideas incubate in the back of the mind, as long as the person cares about the task [2]. Grant says intrinsic motivation makes you more likely to think about the work "when you're not doing the task and come up with great ideas" [2]. Rubin believes the subconscious keeps working while he's away from a project [3][4]. Writing an idea down is what lets it sit safely while that background work happens.

Handwriting may help you remember. Huberman cites research that "you have a better memory for information when you take notes by hand than by keyboard" [2]. The source gives no details of that research, so take it as his summary.

New input keeps the stream going. Sharot's work on habituation says the brain gets used to repeated routines, and new inputs create new connections [1]. Rubin says novelty wakes us up and describes seeing what he hadn't seen before as the start of everything he's made [4]. Strummer's "no input no output" puts it in three words [4]. Capture is the other end of that loop: input produces ideas, and a notebook keeps them.

Writing it down builds a habit, and a sense that your ideas matter. Robbins says that when you capture ideas "you are validating your ideas," and that it makes creativity a habit, and that it is a way of "honoring your own wisdom" [1]. She presents this as her own view, not as research.

Where It Applies, and Where It Doesn't

It applies to anyone who makes things. The examples cover songwriting (Swift) [1], book writing and research (Grant, Huberman, Chris Robbins, who is writing his first book) [1][2], music production (Rubin) [3][4] and science and podcasting (Huberman) [2][4]. Robbins also presents it as a general life habit for anyone who has ideas and loses them [1].

It works best when you actually care about the work. Grant's incubation finding held only when people were intrinsically interested in the task [2]. A capture system for ideas you don't care about is unlikely to produce much.

It isn't a replacement for focused work. Rubin separates collecting seeds from crafting and completion, and says deadlines help in the finishing phases [3][4]. Swift's note pad feeds her songwriting but doesn't replace sitting down to write the chorus [1]. Capture gets the raw material; you still have to build something from it.

It isn't a reason to keep a problem running in your head. Rubin says stewing over a problem doesn't solve it, and he deliberately stops thinking about a project when he leaves it [3][4]. A notebook should help you let go, not become another way to keep grinding.

A system that's scattered doesn't really work. Mel Robbins' note cards "all over the frickin place" and Instagram folders [1] show that capture without one place to look fails at the second stage, the searching that Swift relies on. Huberman's complaint that voice notes are "hard to go back to that in a systematic way" [2] is the same problem.

Capture can collide with the people around you. Huberman admits his morning idea window and constant note-taking are to "the dismay of people in my life" and that he had to make adjustments [2]. A capture habit has to fit around family and conversation.

Rubin's one caution. Because what works is personal, the particular tool that worked for Swift, Chris Robbins or Huberman may not work for you [3]. Test, and change what doesn't stick.

What To Do With It

  1. Pick one capture tool you will always have with you, and make it the only one. Swift uses one "endless note pad" on her phone [1]; Chris Robbins has kept a notebook "that can sit in the back pocket of a pair of khakis" for 30 years [1]. Avoid Mel Robbins' spread of note cards, journals and saved folders [1].

  2. Choose phone or paper based on how you'll go back to it. If you need to search a year of notes by theme, as Swift does, a phone note works well [1]. If the phone distracts you or voice notes pile up unread, try paper, as Huberman does, who also points to research favoring handwriting for memory [2].

  3. Set a low bar and write it down immediately. Swift writes anything that's "a cool observation" or "a cool lyric thing" [1]. Chris Robbins writes at stop signs and while cooking [1]. Don't wait until you get home: as Strummer put it, "if you wait it will be gone" [4].

  4. Capture now, judge later. Follow Huberman's two steps, "grab everything and then filter out what's useful" [2], and Rubin's rule that seed collecting has no deadlines and no verdicts [3][4].

  5. Keep it ready at the times your ideas come. Huberman's best ideas come "within the first hour after waking," so his notebook is nearby [2]. Notice whether yours come in the shower, on walks, in the car or while falling asleep [2], and put your tool there, the way Chris Robbins keeps his notebook out in the truck [1].

  6. Let big ideas sit before you act on them. Do what Grant does with book ideas: "I file it away and I give myself at least a month before I began drafting" [2]. It will feel less productive, but he says it is "far more creative" [2].

  7. Search your notes when you start a new piece of work. When Swift had a chorus, she searched "all my lyrics that I've thought of in the last year" for lines with the right feel [1]. Before starting a project, read back through your notes by theme and cherry-pick.

  8. Feed the system with new input. Wander, change your route, take a free course, try a new podcast or befriend someone unlike your usual crowd, as Sharot suggests [1]. Walk and listen to lectures like Rubin [4]. Then capture what those inputs spark, as Robbins suggests [1].

  9. Watch for repeated clues in your notes. Rubin says one recommendation "maybe it's a coincidence" but three "maybe it's not" [3]. A written record lets you see when the same idea, book or suggestion keeps coming back.

  10. Use writing to see your blind spots. Try Grant's reflected best-self exercise: ask 10 to 20 people for a specific story of you at your best, write them down and look for the patterns you can't see yourself [2]. Treat your opinions as hypotheses to test [2].

Sources

  1. Simple Life Hacks That Will Change Your Future (Steal These Habits From Billionaires) · The Mel Robbins Podcast
  2. Dr. Adam Grant: How to Unlock Your Potential, Motivation & Unique Abilities · Huberman Lab
  3. Rick Rubin on Accessing Creativity: Taste, Presence, and the Four Phases of Creative Work · Huberman Lab
  4. Rick Rubin: How to Access Your Creativity · Huberman Lab

Products and resources from this insight

Some of these are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Perfect Summary is paid a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Perfect Summary earns from qualifying purchases.

  • Hidden Potential · Adam Grant
    Grant's book on the character skills that unlock unexpected growth
  • The Creative Act: A Way of Being · Rick Rubin
    Guest's book on creativity, discussed throughout the episode
  • Rev · Rev.com
    Huberman uses it to turn voice-memo ideas into transcripts.
  • Season of the Witch · David Talbot
    Huberman recommends it as a great book about 1960s San Francisco.

Read next

Report a problem

Something wrong on this page? A mistake, a broken link, audio that won't play? Tell us and we'll fix it.