Insight | Chase happiness directly and it slips away
Tal Ben-Shahar advises pursuing happiness indirectly, Laurie Santos explains hedonic adaptation with the 'yacht problem', Arthur Brooks warns about the hedonic treadmill, and Morgan Housel says money buys happiness only indirectly. Meaning, connection and contribution deliver the happiness that direct pursuit of pleasure or status cannot.
The Short Version
Happiness researchers and teachers on these podcasts keep reaching the same paradox: if you aim at happiness directly, or at the things you assume will deliver it, you tend to end up less happy. Tal Ben-Shahar says the research "clearly shows" that making happiness your goal backfires, and that it has to be pursued indirectly through its parts [1]. Laurie Santos explains that we quickly adapt to money and possessions, illustrated by a multimillionaire whose marriage was strained by where to park a yacht [2]. Arthur Brooks describes the hedonic treadmill, which keeps money, power, pleasure and fame from ever delivering what our brains promise [3]. Morgan Housel says money does buy happiness, but only indirectly, through time, connection and independence [4]. What works instead is time with people you care about, meaning and purpose, giving to others and full attention to the moment. Andrew Huberman adds an important caveat: money still buffers stress, and resources matter more than the slogans admit [5].
Table of contents
What They Said
Tal Ben-Shahar: look at the colors, not the sun
Ben-Shahar taught two of Harvard's most popular courses, positive psychology and the psychology of leadership, and he surprised Mel Robbins with a warning about his own field [1]. Even though he has devoted his life to happiness, he says that making it a direct goal is a mistake: "what the research clearly shows is that this will make you less happy" [1].
His analogy is sunlight. Look straight at the sun and "It burns. It hurts. You tear up" [1]. "However, what if you take a prism and you break the sunlight?" Then you see the colors of the rainbow and can enjoy the light, "But you're looking at it indirectly. It's the same with happiness" [1]. In his words: "Pursuing it directly and saying, I want to be happy. Happiness is important for me that will make us unhappy. But if I break down happiness into its metaphorical colors of the rainbow. And then pursue it indirectly. That is when I can actually become happier" [1].
Robbins applied it to the targets people fix on: finding "the one, making more money, buying a house. That intense focus, she said, is like staring at the sun: It creates blindness, makes you miserable [1]. She admitted she had been waking up every morning telling herself she was going to be happy, and that she'd been doing it wrong [1]. The prism taught her that happiness is more than one thing," so one bad day at work doesn't have to crowd out a sunset or the sight of her dogs playing [1].
His colors are SPIRE [1]:
- Spiritual well-being, through religion, but also through doing something meaningful and purposeful, and through mindfulness and presence. "So if I wake up in the morning and say, I want to be happy, I'll be less happy. But if I wake up in the morning and say, I want to find something which is more meaningful to do. Or I'm going to meditate for 10 minutes now. That is an indirect way of pursuing happiness."
- Physical well-being: exercise, nutrition, rest, sleep and touch.
- Intellectual well-being: curiosity, asking questions, constant learning, and diving deep into a text, a work of art or nature.
- Relational well-being, which he ranks highest: "Number one, predictor of happiness, quality time, we spend with people we care about and who care about us."
- Emotional well-being: giving ourselves permission to be human, since "allowing these emotions to freely flow through us paradoxically, actually leads to more happiness."
The same Robbins compilation includes financial educator Tiffany Aliche, whose story puts the point in human terms. After her husband died suddenly of an aneurysm, she said the gift of grief showed her that everything she teaches about money "is not for money sake. It's for meaning sake" [1]. She hopes people "use your money as one of the tools to help you achieve that life" of connectedness, love and purpose [1]. She had been the driven one, always chasing more, while her husband liked the life they already had. "My husband never made over $60,000 a year," she said, yet he called her parents more than she did and quietly helped a neighbor she had never met [1]. Neurosurgeon Jim Doty, in the same episode, warns against sacrificing everything to reach the top of a mountain only to stand there alone: "Our purpose in life is connection" [1].
Laurie Santos: we chase the wrong things, and then we get used to them
Santos, the Yale cognitive scientist behind Psychology and the Good Life, opens with the claim that most of us get happiness wrong [2]. The problem isn't lack of effort: "It's not so much that we're not seeking happiness out. We are." Some of us put in a lot of work and a lot of money, "But we tend to be taking the things that don't get us there" [2]. Our intuitions about what will make us happy are often wrong [2].
She gives two reasons. The first is evolution. Survivors needed to notice the tiger in the bush, not their blessings, so our brains have a negativity bias, and social media gives it more to latch onto [2]. The second is the belief that happiness comes from circumstances: more money, the perfect grade, a new relationship, a new house or dress [2]. She's careful here. For people without food or shelter, or living in a refugee camp, circumstances matter enormously [2]. But once basic needs are met, big changes in circumstances rarely deliver what we expect [2].
On money she's precise: "does money matter for happiness? Yes, for sure. But it only matters up to a certain level. And that's the spot that we get wrong" [2]. She cites a Daniel Kahneman study, which she dates to around 2009, in which positive emotion rose with income and then leveled off at around $75,000 a year in the U.S., perhaps $100,000 to $110,000 today. Beyond that, doubling or tripling income didn't bring more positive emotion or less stress [2]. Her reasons: higher salaries often mean more work and less time, less social interaction, and hedonic adaptation, simply getting used to things like first-class flights or good restaurants until they no longer give a boost [2]. "It's the fast definition is you just got used to something," she says [2]. It happens even in marriage: "the moment you get married, like basically like five months in, you're already getting used to your partner" [2].
Her most vivid example comes from therapist Clay Cockrell, a guest on her podcast who works only with the ultra-wealthy. Most of his clients earn over $50 million a year. "And the first thing that should be striking is that this dude has clients," she points out [2]. One client had just bought a yacht his wife wanted, and they couldn't figure out where to park it, which was causing serious marital strife [2]. Robbins admitted a petty reaction, glad the yacht owner was unhappy, and they laughed that someone taking the bus would worship Robbins' old car [2]. That's hedonic adaptation at every income level.
Santos suggests breaking adaptation by imagining that something you take for granted, like your car or your job, is suddenly gone [2]. And she points to a better use of money. Robbins realized that what a family vacation really buys is time with family [2]. Santos connects this to Ashley Whillans' research on time affluence. Frequently feeling time-starved is "as big a hit on your well-being as if you self-report being unemployed" [2], and "one of the best ways we can spend our money to increase our happiness is to actually use money to buy back time" [2].
Her five strategies all aim at something other than happiness itself [2]:
- Social connection. Happy people spend more time with others, especially friends and family, whether introvert or extrovert. In Nick Epley's research, commuters paid to talk to strangers on the train expected it to be unpleasant but felt more positive and less lonely. Epley's line: "nobody waves, but everybody waves back."
- Being other-oriented. Spending time and money on others makes us happier, and voluntary kindness even makes us feel like we have more time.
- Presence and gratitude, including Dan Gilbert's finding that minds wander just under half the time, and people are less happy when they do.
- Savoring ordinary moments, like coffee or dishwashing.
- Self-compassion and kinder comparisons.
Santos also distinguishes being happy in your life (day-to-day positive emotion) from being happy with your life (overall satisfaction, meaning and purpose) [2]. You can fly first class and eat at the best restaurants and still, with your life, "feel a little bit empty" without "a sense of purpose, a sense of meaning" [2]. She notes that happiness takes ongoing practice: "It's kind of like a leaky tire" [2].
Arthur Brooks: the hedonic treadmill and the four idols
Brooks, who has studied happiness exclusively since 2019, starts by saying happiness isn't a feeling. Feelings are evidence of it, the way the smell of turkey is evidence of Thanksgiving dinner [3]. His research on people with the highest measured life satisfaction found "three macronutrients to the happiest life. The happiest people have enjoyment, satisfaction, and meaning" [3].
Each one separates the real thing from its imitation. Enjoyment isn't pleasure: "the pursuit of pleasure is not the secret of happiness, it's the secret to rehab" [3]. Pleasure is a limbic, animal phenomenon, and it becomes enjoyment when we add people and memory. His rule: "If you're doing it alone, you're probably doing it wrong" [3]. Satisfaction is "the joy of an accomplishment or an activity after struggle" [3]. Meaning is "the why of your existence" [3].
He also argues that happiness contains unhappiness. "If you spend your life, which many people do today, trying to avoid unhappiness, trying to avoid and eliminate suffering, they will paradoxically miss their own happiness" [3]. He adds that "mother nature doesn't care if you're happy". Negative emotions are alarm signals showing that the brain is working [3].
His explanation of why direct pursuit fails centers on four idols, which he takes from Thomas Aquinas: money, power, pleasure and honor or fame [3]. None is evil. Money brings jobs and philanthropy, and even fame can inspire people. "The problem is it'll hurt you if one of these things is your primary objective" [3]. Our animal impulses lie to us: "They won't deliver the satisfaction that you seek, but your brain tells you that they will. That will put you on what we, in my community, call the hedonic treadmill" [3]. The treadmill works because emotions aren't meant to last. "Emotions are not there to give you a nice day," but to signal threats and opportunities, and "they reset immediately. You always think they're gonna last forever" [3]. He recalls the old bumper sticker that "the person who dies with the most toys wins" [3]. Pursued for their own sake, the idols cost us love, which he calls the secret of happiness [3].
Satisfaction has its own trap. Because "human beings are made to earn their success," hitting a goal ends the progress we're wired for, which is why Olympic athletes can fall into depression after winning gold [3]. He jokes that Mick Jagger should have sung "I can't keep no satisfaction" [3]. Strivers often defer gratification forever because they "don't know what their marshmallow even is" [3]. On fame specifically, he says it's "the only one of the worldly rewards you can only ever be happy in spite of" [3].
His story of a wealthy, unhappy executive shows the cost. She knew exactly what she needed to change but hadn't done it "because I've always chosen to be special rather than happy" [3]. Brooks admits it hit him hard, recalling the Little League games and birthdays he missed while chasing success [3].
His alternative lives in meaning. He says the brain's right hemisphere handles the complex, unsolvable questions of love, faith and purpose, while the left handles "how to and what" [3]. "When you're stuck in the left hemisphere, for example, looking at your phone 205 times a day," then "meaning will be absent" [3]. He calls that the biggest happiness crisis today [3]. He recommends "proper leisure," using unpaid time to deepen relationships on purpose, learn something you don't need to learn, and develop yourself spiritually or philosophically [3]. He also recommends going device-free for the first and last hour of the day and at meals [3]. On faith he offers an order that mirrors Ben-Shahar's indirect route: "Start with practice, occasionally you'll believe, and very occasionally you'll feel it" [3].
Morgan Housel: money buys happiness, indirectly
Housel, author of The Psychology of Money, is the one voice here who says money can buy happiness. He just says it does so indirectly [4]. A big house helps because it makes hosting family and friends easier. An expensive vacation helps because of the memories made with people you love [4]. If a beach vacation with his kids is a 10, playing Legos with them on the living room floor might be an 8.5, because the real source of joy is uninterrupted time together [4].
He explains why lottery winners don't end up happier over time: they gain money without purpose, while people who built something gained purpose along the way [4]. His formula is "independence plus purpose": a purpose bigger than yourself, such as family, faith or work, and the independence to pursue it on your own terms. Money isn't either one, but it can support both [4].
He's blunt about what happens when money is pursued directly. Credit lets people try to fill emotional holes with purchases: the car, then the watch, then a bigger house [4]. He cites Will Smith's reflection that when he was poor and depressed he still hoped money would fix things, but when he was rich and depressed he lost that hope because it hadn't [4]. When money becomes part of your identity, it's "a financial asset and a psychological liability," and if the finish line keeps moving, that looks like addiction [4]. Chasing money to avoid the social pain of falling behind peers is a game no one wins, because someone always has more. He describes a man in a 15,000-square-foot mansion fixated on a neighbor's 17,000-square-foot one [4]. Of fame, he says, "fame restricts your freedom it does not increase your freedom" [4].
His evidence from the end of life points the same way. Gerontologist Karl Pillemer interviewed very old people, and not one said they wished they had earned more money, while nearly all wished they had spent more time with their kids, friends and family [4]. He cites Warren Buffett's advice to write the obituary you want and work backward, and David Brooks' distinction between resume virtues and eulogy virtues [4]. Most people want the second but spend their days chasing the first [4]. For Housel, what money should buy is independence: "every dollar that you don't spend is money that you are actually spending on independence" [4].
The GIST of every new summary in your inbox, daily or weekly. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.
Andrew Huberman: yes, but money and effort still matter
In his solo happiness episode, Huberman accepts most of this but adds nuance [5]. He points out what he calls the contradictions of happiness research: "all of the things that we're told that we need in order to access happiness on a regular basis oftentimes contradict with the pressures and the requirements of not just daily life" but of building a life with the resources for social connection, exercise and good nutrition [5]. As a graduate student and postdoc, pursuing meaningful work separated him from sleep, sunshine and social time [5].
On money, he agrees it can't buy happiness, "but it certainly can buffer stress," for example by paying for childcare, cleaning or a night nurse so new parents can sleep [5]. As a grad student in a small town, he earned little but felt low-stress. As a postdoc, his income rose about 30 to 40% but his living costs rose more, and he was very stressed [5]. Peer group matters too. In a bigger city, his peers' social activities cost more, so money affected his access to connection [5]. He says it would be inaccurate and even disrespectful to claim money doesn't matter, and he recommends savings covering two to 12 months of expenses as a buffer against anxiety [5].
He also corrects a popular story. Dan Gilbert's famous talk suggested that lottery winners and people newly paralyzed report similar happiness a year later. Huberman notes that Gilbert later corrected himself: sudden wealth brings a modest increase in happiness, and people who became paraplegic did report being less happy, even though people are remarkably resilient [5].
Yet his tools confirm the indirect route. He distinguishes natural happiness, from getting things, from synthetic happiness, which we create through deliberate action and mindset and "which turns out to be at least as powerful and perhaps even more powerful" [5]. He's clear this isn't wishful thinking: "I'm not going to tell you that all you have to do is sit in a chair and Imagine being happy in order to feel happy" [5]. Synthetic happiness takes concrete action. His evidence includes:
- Giving. A 2008 study in Science by Elizabeth Dunn and colleagues found that "spending money on others promotes happiness." It starts from the finding that "income has a reliable but surprisingly weak effect on happiness within nations." Among employees receiving bonuses, "the manner which they spent that bonus was a more important predictor of their happiness than the size of the bonus itself" [5]. Giving time and effort counts too, and the benefit grows with how much the recipient needs it [5].
- Focus. Killingsworth and Gilbert's 2010 Science paper, "a wandering mind is an unhappy mind," found that "people were no happier when thinking about pleasant topics than about their current activity," and that mind-wandering seemed to cause unhappiness, not just follow it [5]. He recommends five to 13 minutes of meditation a day as focus training [5].
- Connection, including brief daily exchanges. He recalls finding real meaning in a few words each morning with the janitors in his lab [5]. He adds eye contact, healthy touch and time with pets [5].
- Commitment. People are happier with choices they can't undo than with ones they keep reconsidering [5].
His conclusion ties it together: "our ability to attend and focus really equates to happiness" [5].
Where They Agree, and Where They Don't
They agree that aiming at happiness, or its usual stand-ins, backfires. Ben-Shahar says a direct happiness goal makes you less happy [1]. Santos says we put effort and money into the wrong things [2]. Brooks says the four idols put you on a treadmill [3]. Housel says chasing money as identity is a psychological liability [4]. Huberman reports that income has only a weak effect once basic needs are met [5].
They agree on what works instead. Relationships come first for everyone. Ben-Shahar calls quality time with people who care about us the number one predictor of happiness [1], Santos makes social connection her first strategy [2], Brooks says enjoyment needs people [3], Housel's best memories are time with his kids [4], and Huberman lists quality social connection among the most consistent predictors [5]. Meaning and purpose come next [1][3][4]. Giving is on Santos' list [2] and in Huberman's evidence [5]. Presence is in Ben-Shahar's spiritual color [1], Santos' third strategy [2] and Huberman's framework [5].
They agree that adaptation is why possessions fade. Santos calls it hedonic adaptation [2]. Brooks describes emotions that "reset immediately" [3]. Housel describes the watch-then-house spiral and the moving finish line [4].
They disagree about how much money matters. Housel says money absolutely can buy happiness, indirectly [4]. Santos says it matters, but only up to a point, about $75,000 in the study she cites [2]. Huberman insists it buffers stress, that it would be disrespectful to dismiss it, and that it shapes access to social connection [5]. Brooks warns that money becomes an idol when it's the primary objective [3]. Aliche frames money as a tool for meaning [1]. These positions differ less than they seem. All five say money helps when it buys time, security and connection and hurts when it becomes the goal. They differ mainly in emphasis. Housel and Huberman, who think about resources and daily stress, stress the benefits. Brooks and Ben-Shahar, who focus on meaning, stress the trap.
They disagree about lottery winners. Housel says lottery winners don't end up happier over time because they gained money without purpose [4]. Huberman, citing Gilbert's correction, says sudden wealth brings a modest increase [5]. Both views allow that windfalls deliver far less than people expect.
They seem to disagree about deliberately working on happiness. Santos teaches happiness as a skill that takes practice and says working on your own happiness isn't selfish [2]. Huberman calls synthetic happiness a deliberate, effortful practice [5]. At first this looks like the direct pursuit Ben-Shahar warns against. But look at what they actually practice: connection, kindness, gratitude, savoring, focus, giving. Those are Ben-Shahar's colors [1]. The deliberate effort goes into the ingredients, not into the feeling itself, which is exactly the indirect route.
They differ on unhappiness. Brooks says unhappiness is part of each macronutrient, and that trying to eliminate suffering makes you miss happiness [3]. Ben-Shahar's emotional well-being says the same: allowing painful emotions leads to more happiness [1]. Huberman adds that major trauma really does lower well-being, even though people are resilient [5]. So accepting ordinary unhappiness isn't the same as dismissing real harm.
Why It Works
Adaptation cancels gains in circumstances. We get used to new possessions and experiences until they stop giving a boost [2]. Higher income often brings more work and less time and social contact [2]. Emotions reset quickly because their job is to signal threats and opportunities, not to keep you content [3].
Our predictions are wrong. Santos says our intuitions about what will make us happy are often mistaken [2]. Huberman notes that we're poor at predicting how we'll feel in the future [5]. Brooks says our brains tell us the idols will satisfy us when they won't [3].
Comparison moves the target. Housel's mansion owner fixates on the bigger mansion next door, and someone always has more [4]. Santos says we judge salary and looks against reference points, usually people who seem better off [2]. Huberman says people tend to feel less happy on birthdays after about 25 as they compare themselves to peers [5].
Reaching a goal ends the progress we need. Brooks' point is that satisfaction comes from struggle and accomplishment. Hitting the goal ends the striving we're built for, leaving some high achievers empty [3].
The indirect paths have their own evidence. Talking to strangers raised mood even though people predicted it wouldn't [2]. Prosocial spending predicted happiness independently of income, and how employees spent a bonus mattered more than its size [5]. Mind-wandering, even to pleasant topics, went with lower happiness, and focus on the present went with higher [5]. Feeling time-starved hurts as much as unemployment [2]. And people are happier with choices they commit to [5].
Meaning needs a different mode of thinking. Brooks argues that meaning lives in the brain's integrative, "why side, which a life spent in how to and what," especially on phones, crowds out [3].
Where It Applies, and Where It Doesn't
It applies most once basic needs are met. Santos is explicit that for people without food or shelter, circumstances matter a great deal [2]. Robbins' memory of her bank card bouncing at the gas station shows how financial stress crowds out happiness [2]. Huberman's savings buffer and stress-buffering argument point the same way [5]. If money is short, getting to security is part of the path, not a distraction from it.
It doesn't mean money, work or ambition are bad. Brooks says none of the idols is evil [3]. Housel and Huberman both love their work and would keep doing it without financial need [4][5]. Huberman warns that the no one wishes they'd worked more line needs nuance, since work brings income and often deep meaning [5]. The problem is making money, status or pleasure the primary goal [3].
It doesn't mean ignoring real suffering. Brooks and Ben-Shahar say to let ordinary painful emotions flow [1][3], but Huberman notes that major trauma lowers well-being and that resources for overcoming it matter [5]. Santos, speaking to a college mental health crisis, notes how many students report being too depressed to function [2]. If low mood is persistent or severe, practices like these aren't enough. Talk to a doctor or mental health professional.
Real life won't always cooperate. Huberman's contradictions are real. Building a career or caring for young children can temporarily crowd out sleep, exercise and connection [5]. Santos' distinction helps here. A new parent can be happy with life while miserable in it [2].
What To Do With It
Stop making happiness the morning goal. Replace I'm going to be happy today with one concrete, meaningful act, such as ten minutes of meditation or a task that matters to you, as Ben-Shahar suggests [1].
Schedule time with people you care about. Relational well-being is the top predictor of happiness, so protect it first [1][2]. Add small contacts too. Be the one who waves [2], and say a few words to the people you see every day [5].
Give on purpose. Spend some money, time or effort on others, especially people who truly need it [5]. Try Santos' homework: give at least three meaningful compliments this week [2].
Buy time, not things. Use money to hand off tasks you dislike and to create shared time, like family trips or unhurried evenings, rather than more possessions [2][4].
Name your idol. Play Brooks' elimination game. Cross money, power, pleasure and fame off one at a time until the one most likely to beguile you is left, then watch for when it becomes your main objective [3].
Break adaptation. Imagine something you take for granted, like your car, your job or a person, suddenly gone, and notice its value again [2].
Keep your attention where you are. Practice five to 13 minutes of focus meditation a day [5], and go device-free for the first and last hour of the day and at meals [3].
Build a security buffer, then stop moving the finish line. Aim for savings covering two to 12 months of expenses [5]. Then treat money as a tool for independence and purpose rather than a yardstick against others [4].
Write the obituary you want. Work backward from the eulogy virtues, being a good parent, friend and neighbor, and check whether your days serve them [4].
Let unhappiness be part of it. Allow sadness, anger and frustration to move through you rather than fighting them [1], and remember that satisfaction comes from struggle, not from avoiding it [3].
Sources
- The Top Expert Advice of the Year: The Best of the Mel Robbins Podcast · The Mel Robbins Podcast
- The Science of Well-Being: Powerful Happiness Hacks That 5 Million People Are Using · The Mel Robbins Podcast
- Arthur Brooks on the Three Macronutrients of Happiness, the Four Idols, and Finding Meaning · Huberman Lab
- Morgan Housel: Understand & Apply the Psychology of Money to Gain Greater Happiness · Huberman Lab
- Science-Based Tools for Increasing Happiness · Huberman Lab
Products and resources from this insight
Some of these are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Perfect Summary is paid a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Perfect Summary earns from qualifying purchases.
-
Protect Your Peace · Trent SheltonShelton's bestselling book on boundaries and protecting your energy.
-
How to Break Up with Your Phone · Catherine PriceSource of the WWW check: what for, why now, what else
-
Leisure, the Basis of Culture · Josef PieperBrooks's practical tool: how you use unpaid time reveals who you are
-
The Psychology of Money · Morgan HouselGuest's best-selling book on money behavior, praised by Huberman
-
Trauma: The Invisible Epidemic · Paul Conti(our summary)Huberman calls it the best book on trauma and its treatment
-
Dopamine Nation · Anna Lembke(our summary)Recommended for understanding dopamine, reward and addiction





