Insight | Every theory is an approximation: why good physicists admit ignorance
Andrew Strominger says every theory has edges, Michelle Thaller insists scientists must admit what they do not know, Carlo Rovelli praises humility, and Brian Cox and Lisa Randall describe the limits of science. Their shared stance is a useful guide to how much trust any scientific claim has earned.
Good physicists admit ignorance because every theory is an approximation: a scientific claim is trusted to the extent it has been measured, and everything beyond that has to be labeled as unknown. Five physicists and astronomers, asked separately, describe that same working rule, and it gives a reader a practical test for any claim.
Andrew Strominger of Harvard puts it most bluntly: "Everything is an approximation." Newton's gravity needed corrections, Maxwell's electromagnetism needs quantum mechanics, and general relativity predicts its own breakdown at a singularity. He welcomes that, because the edge of a theory shows exactly where improvement is needed. He calls the standard model the most accurate theory in the history of human thought and also a laundry list of free parameters, and he says he does not believe his own string theory without an experiment.
Michelle Thaller, an astrophysicist and retired NASA executive, says science is limited on purpose, to what is consistently reproducible. A single person's experience may be real, but she cannot run an experiment on it. She lists her field's gaps plainly, including neutron stars, the first instant of the universe and what time is.
Carlo Rovelli argues that certainty is what blocks understanding. Of his own loop quantum gravity he says it is not yet confirmed, because ideas have to be tested. Brian Cox says science is a humble pursuit and that its success comes from being "delighted when you're wrong." His example is Brian Schmidt, who doubted his own finding that the universe's expansion is speeding up, published it anyway so others could find the mistake, and won the Nobel Prize. Lisa Randall labels her own dark matter idea as speculative, and warns from the Large Hadron Collider that you should not assume what an experiment will find before it has found it.
They disagree on specifics, openly. Rovelli says electrons exist only when they interact; Randall replies that something is there the whole time. Thaller is wary of theories about the first fractions of a second, Cox treats inflation as part of the standard picture, and Rovelli would bet on a bounce. Strominger and Rovelli work on rival approaches to quantum gravity, and each downgrades his own.
Humility about theory is not doubt about measurement. Time dilation is everyday engineering in GPS, and Strominger says black holes definitely exist. Nor is it a license to believe anything: Thaller insists that unexplained is not the same as alien. Some of the open results discussed were disputed or unconfirmed when recorded, so the article advises checking the current position.
What to do with it: ask whether a claim has been reproduced by people other than the one making it. Count the independent lines of evidence. Separate what is measured from what is inferred and what is conjectured. Look for the label, the moment a source says this part is speculative or unknown. Ask where a theory stops working; a source that cannot name that place has not earned much trust. Treat an unexplained result as unexplained and suspect the instrument first. Notice when you are defending an idea because it is yours.





