Insight | Getting to another star: what scientists think is actually possible
Sara Seager and David Kipping both discuss how we might reach other stars, and Ann Druyan tells the story of Voyager and its Golden Record, the craft already on its way out. Together they give a sober picture of the distances involved and of what has been done so far.
The Short Version
Reaching another star is possible in principle and far beyond anything built so far, and the scientists who think about it have largely stopped imagining crewed ships. Sara Seager says that getting to the nearest Earth-mass planet "would take tens of thousands of years to get there with conventional methods", and suggests that sending instructions to print humans might be easier than sending people [1]. David Kipping says thinking has moved from fusion-powered starships toward gram-scale probes pushed by lasers to a fraction of light speed, with many launched so that some survive [2]. Both describe a second route that avoids the trip, a telescope placed about 500 times the Earth-Sun distance to use the Sun's gravity as a lens [1][2]. Against those plans stands what has actually been done: the two Voyager spacecraft, which Ann Druyan helped send off in 1977 with a golden record aboard, have reached the edge of the Sun's domain and will drift through the galaxy for a billion years or more [3]. The sober picture is that we have left a calling card at the doorstep, and the first real visit, if it comes, will probably be made by something the size of a chip [1][2][3].
Table of contents
What They Said
Sara Seager: so hard that printing people might be easier
Seager, an MIT planetary scientist who searches for worlds around other stars, starts with the target. The nearest star to Earth, Proxima Centauri, more than four light years away, appears to have a planet of about Earth's mass in its habitable zone [1]. She finds the coincidence remarkable: "even the very nearest star has planets and has a planet of huge interest to us" [1].
Then she states the distance in terms of time. Reaching it "would take tens of thousands of years to get there with conventional methods" [1]. That is the origin of the multi-generational ship of science fiction, in which the people who arrive are the remote descendants of those who left [1]. Seager's own speculation goes around the problem: "maybe we don't send people. Maybe we end up sending raw biological materials and instructions to print out humans." [1] It sounds far-fetched, she concedes, but laboratories are already printing liver cells and beating heart cells [1]. Her reasoning is a measure of the difficulty: "it is so hard to get to another planet that this thought of printing humans or printing life forms actually could be easier" [1]. Her host, Lex Fridman, finds it sad that such a ship might arrive after human civilization is gone [1].
She is clear about the order of work. Before visiting, we have to find Earth-like planets, which she calls a "needle in a haystack, but worse" that will cost billions of dollars, because an Earth is so small and faint beside its star [1]. And the search itself is confined to our neighborhood. In practical terms the star has to be close, "a few light years tens of light years maybe hundreds of light years" away, and the number of stars with planets suitable for detailed follow-up is small: "I'm talking about maybe a dozen or two dozen stars." [1] Her expectation is that telescopes will deliver a hint of life, and that it will fall to future generations "to hopefully even find a way to send a probe to these distant exoplanets" [1].
She describes two projects that are not hers and that she loves anyway [1].
The first is Breakthrough Starshot. The plan is thousands of tiny "star chips" with solar sails a few meters wide, pushed by gigawatt lasers on the ground to about a twentieth of the speed of light, so that they could reach the nearest star in about 20 years, fly past, take photographs and send them back [1]. The project listed 19 challenges, from buying land and getting airspace approval to building sails the lasers will not vaporize [1]. Seager's judgment is that even if the money does not make it happen, the idea has "planted the seed" and moved the line between crazy and real [1].
The second avoids travel to the star altogether. It is "the idea to send a telescope very far away to 500 times the earth's sun distance", where the Sun's gravity acts as a lens, a real astronomical tool that goes back to Einstein [1]. It would take about 25 years to get there and might return an image of perhaps 10 by 10 pixels, and it needs a separate telescope for each target [1].
Her own project, Starshade, is about seeing and not going: a flower-shaped screen about 30 meters across, flying tens of thousands of kilometers from a space telescope, to block a star's light so that a planet 10 billion times fainter can be seen [1]. She tells its history as a lesson in how such ideas mature. It was first conceived in the 1960s and revisited every decade until it became buildable, and when she took on a leadership role, "It was on the giggle factor side of the line." [1] The team worked through a list of the hardest problems one at a time [1]. Fridman's summary of the method: "Take a big, crazy idea and break it down into smaller, crazy ideas, order it in a list, and knock it out one of the time." [1]
Seager also welcomes what makes any of this cheaper to attempt. Reusable rockets from SpaceX and other companies lower the cost of reaching space, which helps her field, and she supports sending humans to Mars mainly because the urge to explore is part of being human [1].
David Kipping: small probes, borrowed energy and a lens the size of the Sun
Kipping, a Columbia University astronomer, gives the engineering options in order of ambition [2].
Fusion-powered ships of the kind studied in Project Daedalus and Project Icarus might reach about 10 percent of light speed [2]. But he says thinking has shifted toward gram-scale probes pushed by lasers to about 20 percent of light speed, mass-produced so that some survive the journey, with humans perhaps visiting digitally [2]. The shift is from one large vehicle carrying people to many tiny ones carrying sensors.
His own contribution is the Halo Drive, which builds on Freeman Dyson's idea of slingshotting ships around pairs of neutron stars. Instead of flying a ship into that violent environment, you fire a laser that loops around a binary black hole, returns blue-shifted with extra energy, and pushes the ship [2]. He describes the attitude behind such schemes: "I often think of the universe as like a big computer game and you're trying to find cheat codes." [2]
He draws a firm line at faster-than-light travel. He is skeptical of warp drives because you cannot have relativity, faster-than-light travel and causality all at once [2].
Like Seager, he points to observation as the alternative to travel. The Sun's gravity focuses light about 550 astronomical units away, far enough out to image planets at kilometer resolution, which makes him wonder whether aliens simply observe Earth from afar [2]. His team's more practical idea, the terrascope, uses refraction in Earth's atmosphere, with a useful focus about three or four times the Earth-Moon distance [2].
Kipping adds considerations that frame the whole question. On whether anyone could cross the galaxy, he cites simulations suggesting that even slow ships could fill it within about a million years, so the fact that we are here undisturbed is perhaps the one solid data point about other civilizations [2]. On our own starting position, he notes a colleague's paper suggesting that civilizations on super-Earths might never escape their planet's gravity with chemical rockets, and finds it almost spooky that Earth offers gravity weak enough for rockets and a Moon within reach [2]. On robotic exploration, he points out that even at Mars the light-travel delay means no human can steer a landing, so the entire sequence runs autonomously [2]. Anything sent to a star would be on its own to a far greater degree.
He is a realist about people going anywhere. He supports becoming multiplanetary as insurance but has no wish to live on Mars, which he calls a dry, frozen, radioactive desert, and he doubts thousands will live there in his lifetime [2]. The question, he says, is "will we get out of the nest before we burn it down." [2]
And he connects the subject to messages. Civilizations may be common but short-lived, so we may simply not overlap; that makes records sent through time the most selfless kind of communication [2]. He suggests the Moon, which has no weathering, as the best place to leave one, and he is on a team creating an open-source successor to the Voyager Golden Record. He argues that such a record should include uncensored biology and should not assume aliens have eyes [2].
Ann Druyan: the craft already on its way
Druyan was creative director of NASA's Voyager Interstellar Message Project, and she describes the one thing humanity has actually launched toward the stars [3].
Voyager 1 and 2 were, in her words, "our first reconnaissance of the outer solar system" [3]. They were made possible by an alignment of the planets that happens roughly every 175 years and by gravitational assists, which will eventually send both craft wandering the Milky Way for one to five billion years [3]. They gave the first close views of Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus and Neptune, discovered new moons and the volcanoes on Io, and, because the two craft traveled in different directions, revealed the shape of the solar system as it moves through the galaxy [3]. Both reached the heliopause, where the solar wind dies down and the interstellar medium begins [3].
The engineering impresses her as much as the science. The spacecraft were designed to last about a dozen years; 42 years after launch, "we're still talking to them," running on something like 11 watts, "less energy than you have in your toaster." [3] About a year before she spoke, engineers fired Voyager's thrusters for the first time since 1987 and they worked at once [3]. She calls Voyager "the greatest scientific achievement of the 20th century." [3]
Each craft carries the Golden Record. Because Frank Drake, Carl Sagan and Linda Salzman Sagan had made the plaque for the earlier Pioneer 10, a kind of "license plate for the planet Earth," NASA asked Drake and Sagan to create a message for Voyager [3]. The cover is engraved with scientific symbols explaining Earth's address. The record holds around 118 images of life on Earth, 27 pieces of music from around the world, and a sound essay telling the planet's story from geology to biology to technology [3]. Druyan is realistic about its audience: there is a very small chance that a spacefaring civilization would be able to flag one of the craft down [3].
She added something of her own. She asked Sagan whether a recording of the signals from her brain and body during an hour of meditation might someday be decoded by extraterrestrials. His answer was that a billion years is a long time, so she should go and do it [3]. She thought through the history of the planet, the origin and evolution of life, and the predicament of 1977, when "There are some 60,000 nuclear weapons on the planet" and one in five people was starving or without clean water; she had also, days earlier, fallen in love with Sagan [3]. "I was truly humbled by the idea that these thoughts could conceivably touch the distant future," she says [3].
The record was argued over. The team debated whether to show only humanity's best side or also Hiroshima, Auschwitz and the Congo [3]. A picture of a naked man and woman, followed by images of human reproduction, drew a congressman's accusation that NASA was sending smut to the stars, and NASA removed it. Druyan's reaction was that "we couldn't bear to be seen as we are" [3]. She thinks the omissions hardly matter, since any civilization able to catch the craft would recognize it as the work of a people in their technological adolescence: "They would fill in the blanks." [3]
Asked what we would send today, she says we could send everything on the web, with no one acting as gatekeeper [3]. She notes that the computer that recorded her brainwaves in 1977 filled a room and had less power than a modern phone [3].
Her wider view is a caution about will. She compares humanity to a toddler who scurried out to the Moon, had a moment of realizing what it could do, then lost its nerve and ran back. We have the engineering, materials science and physics to do much more, she says, but we are "a little bit paralyzed." [3]
The GIST of every new summary in your inbox, daily or weekly. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.
Where They Agree, and Where They Don't
They agree on the scale of the problem. Seager's tens of thousands of years by conventional means, Kipping's ceiling of a tenth to a fifth of light speed for the most ambitious designs, and Voyager's four decades to reach only the edge of the Sun's influence describe the same wall [1][2][3].
Seager and Kipping agree that the first travelers will be small and robotic. Both describe laser-driven probes with light sails as the leading idea, sent in large numbers, flying past and reporting back [1][2]. Neither expects people aboard; Kipping imagines humans visiting digitally, and Seager imagines sending the instructions for life instead of the living [1][2].
They agree that looking is nearer than going. Both describe the solar gravitational lens, and each has a telescope concept of their own, Seager's Starshade and Kipping's terrascope [1][2]. Seager says we must find the right planets before thinking of a visit [1].
They agree that unlikely ideas become real slowly. Seager's account of the giggle factor, Kipping's remark about cheat codes and Druyan's toddler who lost its nerve all concern the gap between what physics permits and what a civilization commits to [1][2][3].
They differ on some numbers. Seager gives the laser-sail speed as about a twentieth of the speed of light with a trip of about 20 years; Kipping gives about 20 percent of light speed [1][2]. For a star a little over four light years away, a 20-year crossing corresponds to Kipping's figure, so the two accounts cannot both be exact, and the sources do not settle it. They also give slightly different distances for the Sun's focus, about 500 and about 550 times the Earth-Sun distance, and different expectations for the image, about 10 by 10 pixels in Seager's telling and kilometer resolution in Kipping's [1][2].
They differ on sending people at all. Seager entertains generation ships and printed humans as serious if distant possibilities [1]. Kipping doubts large settlements even on Mars within his lifetime [2]. Druyan thinks the obstacle is nerve more than capability [3].
They differ on what a message is for. Druyan tells of a record made for a finder a billion years away, with only a small chance of being found [3]. Kipping wants a successor placed where it will last, such as the Moon, and designed without assuming the finder is like us [2]. Seager, speaking of signals, notes that if every civilization only listens, no one makes progress [1].
They differ in tone. Seager stands behind the bold projects, Kipping pairs inventive physics with caution, and Druyan speaks as someone who has already put something on the way [1][2][3].
Why It Works
Speed is the whole problem. With chemical rockets the nearest star is tens of thousands of years away [1]. Every serious proposal is a way to go much faster with much less mass.
Leave the engine at home. A light sail carries no fuel; the energy comes from lasers on the ground, which is why the craft can be a gram-scale chip and why the challenges include sails that survive the beam [1][2].
Send many. Mass production accepts that most probes will fail and counts on a few arriving [2].
Borrow momentum. Voyager reached the outer planets by gravitational assists made possible by a rare alignment [3]. Kipping's Halo Drive is the same idea taken to an extreme, taking energy from orbiting black holes by way of light [2].
Use gravity as an optic. The Sun bends light to a focus hundreds of times the Earth-Sun distance away; a telescope placed there turns the Sun into a lens, and Kipping says the same could be done on a small scale with Earth's atmosphere [1][2].
Build simply and for the long term. Voyager was designed for a dozen years, still answers after 42, and runs on about 11 watts [3].
Break the impossible into a list. Starshade's team worked through its hardest problems one by one, and Starshot published 19 of its own [1].
Where It Applies, and Where It Doesn't
Nothing has yet been sent to another star. The Voyagers have reached the heliopause, where the interstellar medium begins, but they will wander the galaxy for a billion years or more without a destination [3].
A flyby is not a visit. The laser-sail plan returns photographs from a pass at a fraction of light speed [1]. Stopping, landing and carrying people are not part of it.
The proposals are early. Seager says Starshot may never be funded to completion, and that the gravitational-lens mission needs a telescope per target and about 25 years of travel before its first image [1]. Kipping's Halo Drive requires a pair of black holes [2].
Faster than light is not on the table. Kipping rules out warp drives on grounds of causality [2].
The limits may be social. Druyan's diagnosis is paralysis, and Kipping asks whether we leave the nest before we burn it down [2][3]. Seager notes the search for a target will cost billions [1].
Only the near neighborhood is in reach. Seager's dozen or two dozen stars bound even the looking [1].
What To Do With It
Keep the distances in mind when you read a headline. Tens of thousands of years by conventional rocket, about two decades for a laser sail that has not been built, and a billion years of drifting for the craft already launched [1][2][3].
Expect chips before crews. The plan that scientists take most seriously sends gram-scale probes, many at a time [1][2].
Watch the telescopes. Starshade, the solar gravitational lens and the terrascope are ways of studying another world without leaving ours, and Seager puts finding the target first [1][2].
Follow the cost of launch. Seager says reusable rockets make every such project easier to attempt [1].
Judge a bold proposal by its list of problems. Starshade went from a joke to an engineering plan by naming and solving its hardest ones [1].
Think about what you would put on a record. Druyan's team argued about showing our worst alongside our best, and Kipping says not to assume the finder has eyes [2][3].
Value what lasts. A spacecraft built for twelve years that still works after forty-two is an argument for patience and careful engineering [3].
Take the long view. Druyan's message from Cosmos is "that we have to think in longer terms.", in centuries, which is the only scale on which a journey to a star makes sense [3].
Sources
- Sara Seager on the Search for Exoplanets, Signs of Life, and Finding Light After Loss · Lex Fridman Podcast
- David Kipping on Exomoons, Habitable Worlds and Why We Must Stay Agnostic About Aliens · Lex Fridman Podcast
- Ann Druyan on Cosmos, Carl Sagan, the Voyager Golden Record and the Beauty of Science · Lex Fridman Podcast
Products and resources from this insight
Some of these are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Perfect Summary is paid a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Perfect Summary earns from qualifying purchases.
-
The Smallest Lights in the Universe · Sara SeagerSeager's memoir weaving exoplanet science with losing her husband.
-
The Giver · Lois LowrySeager's top pick; a young adult novel that jolts you out of your own reality.
-
Eyes on Exoplanets · NASANASA tool Seager showed Lex for exploring nearby exoplanets.
-
Cosmos: Possible Worlds · Ann DruyanDruyan jokes she will make Lex buy her companion book to the series.





