Insight | Is quantum mechanics missing something? Three physicists on what is real
Roger Penrose argues quantum mechanics is incomplete and that gravity may change it, Lisa Randall asks whether electrons exist when no one is looking, and Michelle Thaller describes entanglement and a connected universe. Their different answers show that the theory's predictions are settled while its meaning is not.
Three physicists give three different answers to whether quantum mechanics is missing something. None of them disputes that its predictions work. The experiments are settled and widely confirmed. What they say about the world is still argued among people who use the theory every day.
Roger Penrose says outright that the theory is incomplete and, in a certain sense, not quite right. His worry began in a lecture by Paul Dirac on superposition, the idea that a particle can be here and there at the same time. The theory's basic equation, the Schrödinger equation, is deterministic and never yields a single definite result. The step to one outcome, called the collapse of the wave function, is added separately. Without it, he says, the theory does not relate to the world we see. He reads Schrödinger's famous cat as its author's protest that this is an absurdity, and he counts Einstein, Schrödinger and Dirac as doubters too. He thinks gravity supplies the missing piece: "It's not just you quantize gravity. You've got to gravitate quantum mechanics." He is frank that he has no theory and no experiment yet, and that he belongs to a minority within a minority.
Lisa Randall, a Harvard theoretical physicist, sees no need to rewrite the theory. For her the wave function is real, and an electron is there whether or not anyone measures it. Her analogy is a stock: it may have no exact value until it is traded, but you can still estimate its worth, and it exists. It would be very strange, she says, if things came into being only when she looked. She calls the argument a disagreement about how to interpret quantum mechanics, and her habit is to exhaust existing frameworks before reaching for radical ones. She does not claim the theory is final.
Michelle Thaller, an astrophysicist, starts from experiment. Entanglement, in which two connected particles respond to each other at any distance, is an experimental fact, confirmed since the 1990s. Einstein disliked the idea and called it spooky action at a distance. Her reading is that the two particles are one quantum system and the space between them does not matter. From there she asks questions she marks as conjecture, such as whether we are entangled with everything. Her conclusion is the most open: "I don't think we understand yet what reality is."
All three agree the phenomena are real and that an observer does not conjure the world. They disagree on whether the theory must change: Penrose says yes, Randall treats the puzzle as interpretation. Penrose and Thaller both locate the trouble where gravity meets quantum theory, though only Penrose makes gravity the cause of collapse. These were separate conversations, so none answers the others directly.
What to do with it: when you read about quantum physics, separate what was measured from what is being interpreted. Keep the stock analogy in mind: lacking a definite value is different from not existing. Read Schrödinger's cat as an argument that something is missing. Do not put the observer at the center. Notice how each expert labels a claim as fact, view or conjecture. Do not use quantum strangeness to support whatever you would like to be true, and be comfortable with a question that is still open.





