Insight | Pull, don't push: how psychologists help a loved one actually change
Dolly Chugh's model, invite and reward approach, Mel Robbins' advice to make change the other person's idea, Adam Grant's motivational interviewing and Stuart Ablon's collaborative problem solving all reject lecturing in favor of drawing change out of the other person. If you really need someone to change, the methods that work look nothing like the nagging most people default to.
The short answer: you help someone you love change by pulling rather than pushing. Lecturing, nagging, pressuring and giving advice nobody asked for rarely produce lasting change, and they often make it less likely. What works is drawing the change out of the other person so that it becomes theirs.
Four experts reach this verdict from different directions. Social psychologist Dolly Chugh explains why change is hard. The brain runs mostly on autopilot to save energy, and the ego guards our identity and sense of agency, so being told what to do feels like a threat. Her model is blunt: you can model change, invite it and reward it, "but you cannot make anyone change." Modelling means practising the change yourself first. Inviting means giving grace to clumsy first attempts. Rewarding means telling people you noticed their effort. She admits pull takes longer than push but says it lasts longer. She also suggests asking whether someone wants to be heard, hugged, helped or high-fived. Most just want to be heard.
Self-help host Mel Robbins argues that wanting someone to change usually stops them from changing. She cites research that only three percent of people change when the change feels forced, against 37 percent when they believe the idea came from themselves. Her husband Chris got her to rethink her drinking with a question that turned her attention to her own glass, not by telling her she had a problem.
Organizational psychologist Adam Grant recommends motivational interviewing, a method from addiction counselling. You ask open questions, reflect back what you hear, and help the person find their own reasons. He learned this after a former student called him a logic bully. He says we should only preach what we already practise.
Clinical psychologist Stuart Ablon says the one reliable predictor of change is the helping relationship. His Collaborative Problem Solving has three steps. Start with empathy. Then share your concern rather than your solution. Then brainstorm together until both sets of concerns are met. In his words, "people want advice far less often than we think."
The main disagreement is about why people get stuck. Robbins starts from the idea that if they wanted to, they would. That helps you accept other adults and read them by their actions. Ablon insists people do well if they can. In his view a stuck person usually lacks skills such as flexibility, frustration tolerance or problem solving, not motivation, and pressure aimed at a skill gap can make things worse. Robbins softens her rule for depression, missing support or her own ADHD, but Ablon thinks the skill explanation applies far more widely.
They also differ on how much to engage. Robbins leans towards stepping back, Ablon towards stepping in collaboratively, and Grant sits in between. Chugh jokes about bribery, while Ablon argues that rewards and consequences erode inner drive.
None of them treats pulling as endless patience. Chugh warns about support sliding into enabling. Robbins draws boundaries around what she is available for. Ablon's Plan C is a strategic pause, not giving in. Pulling improves the odds but doesn't guarantee change, and it fails if it is really a disguised push.
So, practically: check your own motive and ask what the person wants before advising. Lead with understanding, share your worry rather than your fix, and ask questions that let them own the idea. Practise the change yourself and notice their effort. If someone you love is struggling with addiction, depression or another mental health condition, these approaches can shape how you talk with them, but get the advice of a qualified professional.





