Insight | Stay a beginner: why beginner's mind outlasts expertise

September 29, 2026 · 25 min read

Rick Rubin sees the beginner's advantage in creativity, Josh Waitzkin calls beginner's mind our best defense against AI, Jay Shetty praises the power of being a beginner, and Bryan Callen links ego to getting in your own way. Keeping a beginner's openness protects learning from the rigidity that expertise and success tend to bring.

The insight in about three minutes.

Expertise and success tend to harden into rules, habits and identities that people then defend, and that rigidity is what quietly stops learning. The answer from a music producer, a chess champion, a former monk and two comedians is the same: keep a beginner's openness on purpose, because experience will not keep it for you.

Rick Rubin credits his early breakthroughs to having no experience. He did not know which rules he was breaking, so he did things others would not. Children, he says, are more creative because they carry no beliefs about how things are supposed to work. Rules and borrowed styles build skill but narrow what we see. He warns that a method that worked once is "just a way" and not the right way, and that expert advice reflects the expert's life, not yours. Late in his career he still learned something new about his own process: deadlines help in the finishing phase.

Josh Waitzkin argues that much of high-level learning is unlearning the ego's blocks. Children are not afraid of looking bad until about nine to twelve. Adults cannot return to that innocence, so they must rebuild openness deliberately. Losing an early championship taught him that winning takes struggle. He always played stronger opponents and took on his weaknesses. Successful people, he says, attach their identity to a mental model until "the groove becomes a rut," and teams start protecting a lead. After an injury ended his grappling, he became a beginner again in the ocean. He gives the idea urgency. Machines already far outplay the best humans at chess, and he expects the same elsewhere, so people must practice reinventing themselves.

Jay Shetty advises always putting yourself in rooms where you are not the most successful person. Failure is toxic only when taken personally. Seen as feedback, it is a mirror. Identity should be evolved, not defended.

Bryan Callen and Joe Rogan locate the problem in ego. Most people think about themselves all the time, and progress means getting out of your own way. Callen says each new comedy special is as hard as the first. Rogan does something difficult every day as a reminder of his limits.

They differ on outside feedback. Rubin wants artists to trust their own taste and treat opinions as information to use or not. Waitzkin wants an honest scoreboard, like a rating. The article reads this as a difference between art and competition. They also differ on effort. Rubin is gentle and receptive, Waitzkin intense.

The article sets limits. Beginner's mind does not mean discarding skill, since deep early training still matters. It does not mean deferring to every voice. And it is no license for physical risk. Waitzkin blacked out underwater after a breathing exercise and warns never to do such breathing in water. Get guidance from a qualified professional before starting a demanding physical practice or breathwork.

What to do with it: take up something you are bad at, in public. Seek out rooms and partners that outmatch you. Ask of each routine whether it is the best way or only the one that worked before. Keep a decision journal. Treat failure as a mirror. Question one inherited belief. Do not protect the lead.

This is the short form. The full insight has every expert's reasoning, their own words and the sources.

Read next

Report a problem

Something wrong on this page? A mistake, a broken link, audio that won't play? Tell us and we'll fix it.