Insight | Why the justice system resists admitting its mistakes

September 29, 2026 · 26 min read

A defense attorney and ex-prosecutor describe prosecutors' egos and immunity in the Ohio 4 case, Rod Blagojevich calls his case rigged, and Woody Harrelson recounts the Kids for Cash scandal. The pattern shows how incentives keep errors from being corrected.

Listen to this insight

The Short Version

Across three conversations on The Joe Rogan Experience, a wrongful-conviction lawyer, a former county prosecutor, a former governor who served nearly eight years in federal prison, and Rogan himself describe one pattern: the people who run the justice system are rewarded for winning, face few consequences for getting it wrong, and have strong personal and institutional reasons never to say we made a mistake [1][2][3]. In the Ohio 4 case, Josh Dubin and former prosecutor J.D. Tomlinson describe how a conviction built on a paid informant who later admitted he lied has survived for three decades, and how a joint motion to free the men was reversed within days once a new prosecutor, tied to the original trial prosecutor, took office [1]. Rod Blagojevich argues that federal prosecutors turned political horse-trading into crimes, hid about 98% of the wiretaps and punished him for fighting back, calling it "a rigged criminal justice system" [2]. In the Woody Harrelson episode, Rogan recounts the Pennsylvania "Kids for Cash" judge who sent children to detention for kickbacks [3]. The common thread is incentives: prosecutorial immunity, the drive to win, career loyalty, political power and money all push against admitting error, and the few fixes the guests offer (accountability, defense experience for prosecutors, and the humility to apologize) are aimed squarely at those incentives [1][2][3].

Table of contents

What They Said

Josh Dubin: a case that fell apart from the start, and a system that would not let go

Josh Dubin, a wrongful-conviction attorney, returned to Rogan's show to follow up on the case of the "Ohio 4": Al Cleveland, John Edwards, Lenworth Edwards and Benson Davis, four out-of-town men convicted of a 1991 murder in Lorain County, Ohio [1]. As he tells it, police had singled the men out as people to look at before there was any evidence against them [1]. The case came together only after the prosecutor's office offered a $2,500 reward, when a longtime paid informant, William Avery Sr., came forward and then brought in his son, William Avery Jr., who eventually claimed Cleveland had confessed to him [1].

Dubin's account is that the story collapsed almost at once, and that the system chose not to notice. Avery Jr. described a violent fight in an apartment, but police photos showed the apartment untouched [1]. At the first trial, Dubin says, Avery Jr. tried to extort the prosecutors: "he tells the prosecutors I want $10,000," and when they insisted he testify, "he says I made the whole thing up anyways I did it for the reward money I made it up" [1]. Dubin's judgment on that moment is blunt: "they should have known right then and there" [1]. Instead, they kept Avery Jr. in jail for contempt, the judge declared a mistrial, and "about a month goes by and William Avery junior story has now evolved he now no longer claims that Al Cleveland confessed to him he claims that he was a witness to it" [1]. He testified at all four trials [1].

Dubin adds that the lead prosecutor had been warned: the US Secret Service told him it had stopped using Avery Jr. as an informant because he took reward money for false information [1]. All four men were still convicted and sentenced to 25 years to life [1]. In 2004 Avery Jr. walked into the FBI unprompted and said his drug-addicted father had pressured him into falsely accusing the men, and in 2006 he signed an affidavit saying the same [1]. A federal appeals court later wrote, "We find that Cleveland has presented a credible claim of actual innocence," citing the recantations and evidence that Cleveland was in New York hours before the killing [1]. Dubin notes that Cleveland had met his New York probation officer that day and was seen with Daymond John of Shark Tank [1].

Even then the recantation did not free anyone. At the resulting hearing the judge warned Avery Jr. about perjury charges, and he declined to testify [1]. Outside, he told reporters: "I made the whole thing up. These guys didn't do it, but I'm not going to jail for 25 years." [1] That detail is the pattern in miniature: the one person whose false story built the case had every reason to keep quiet once the system made telling the truth personally dangerous. As Tomlinson points out, the only person who ever placed himself at the scene, Avery Jr., is the only one never charged [1].

On the structural question, Dubin is clear that the grand jury, supposedly the check that screens out weak cases, does not do that job. He cites the famous line from a New York judge that "you can indict a ham sandwich," explaining that "the standard is Much lower than it is to convict" [1]. The defense cannot present evidence or even be in the room: "It is quite literally This is not hyperbole. It is quite literally a one-sided affair" [1]. The number of cases that go before grand juries and are not indicted is, in his estimate, "probably less than 0.001" [1].

His central argument is about immunity. When Rogan proposes an independent panel to vet cases before trial, Dubin calls it "a fantastic idea" but says it would be like moving a mountain, and offers what he calls an easier fix: accountability [1]. "Prosecutors have immunity There are no consequences," he says, and in wrongful-conviction cases "Prosecutors don't turn over evidence that would point to their innocence" [1]. Turning over exculpatory evidence is "constitutionally Required," he notes, "but these prosecutors don't have any accountability" [1].

Dubin also frames the problem as a human one. Real reform, he says, requires prosecutors to be able to say they made a mistake, and he compares it to realizing in the middle of an argument with his wife that he was the one who was wrong [1]. He closes the episode with a line that sums up his view: "The humanity in all of us should always bend toward the truth." [1] He also describes his own shift toward the middle: getting to know prosecutors and law enforcement people "that feel just as passionate about issues that are on the other side" has been, in his words, "eye opening and Incredibly rewarding" [1].

J.D. Tomlinson: the prosecutor who changed sides, then felt the system from the inside

J.D. Tomlinson is the former prosecuting attorney of Lorain County, the office that convicted the Ohio 4 [1]. His story shows both what it takes for a prosecutor to admit an error and what happens to one who does.

His path to the case began with Dubin publicly calling him out on Rogan's show for ignoring his messages while read receipts showed he was reading them [1]. Tomlinson called that same evening, saying he was under enormous stress and flooded with calls; Dubin told him that now he knew what it was like to be accused of something he didn't do, and asked him to imagine 30 years of it [1]. Tomlinson's answer: "if I don't at least agree to meet with you, who am I?" [1] The case had already stuck with him: as a 27-year-old lawyer in 2008, he happened to be in the courtroom when Al Cleveland begged Avery Jr. to tell the truth [1]. He spent Thanksgiving, canceling a trip to Mexico City with his parents, going through the trial record, visiting the apartment and looking for any evidence of guilt, and never found it [1]. He calls Avery Jr. perhaps the worst witness he had ever seen, and says a defense lawyer from one of the original trials used to cry after calls from his client, convinced he had failed an innocent man [1].

Tomlinson credits two things for his openness. The first was an earlier exoneration he had led. In 2022 he cleared Nancy Smith, a Head Start bus driver, and Joseph Allen, convicted in 1994 of a child sex-abuse scheme [1]. He says the original detective found no evidence a crime had occurred and couldn't even show the two knew each other, but parents organized and the stories merged; Allen's home was built on a slab and had no basement, where the abuse was supposed to have happened [1]. Smith served 15 years and Allen 25 [1]. When Tomlinson apologized to them in court, a lawyer from the Innocence Project told him he was the only prosecutor he had ever heard "actually apologize to a defendant" [1]. He then stipulated to their innocence so they could be compensated, which drew criticism, and says Smith is still fighting the state for modest statutory compensation of around 50-something thousand dollars a year [1].

Both the Head Start case and the Ohio 4 case had been prosecuted by the same assistant prosecutor, and Tomlinson says his review of just those two cases found "six people were wrongly convicted and did about 162 years in prison," which makes him wonder how many more there are [1]. That, in his telling, is why the experience with "the assistant prosecutor that was involved in these cases" and "the Nancy Smith" matter was so important to his thinking [1].

The second thing was his background. "Doing 15 years of being a defense attorney. I know how easy it is to do for the stuff to happen it happens," he says [1]. He argues that defense work "changes the way you think about prosecution," and proposes requiring county prosecutors to have had some experience as defense attorneys, "because you get to see it from that Perspective and you never are the same because you understand how these things happen" [1]. He is careful not to condemn the whole system: "I think most of the time it works most of the time But when it doesn't work, it's awful" [1]. He also points out where the real power sits, telling people to "vote local" because the county prosecutor has more power over their lives than the president [1].

Tomlinson also speaks directly to ego. "I've always tried to pride myself on Um, admitting when I'm wrong and knowing when I'm wrong and knowing when I don't know," he says, adding that pretending to know is its own problem: "if you're just guessing you're just lying really" [1]. "I tried to always put my ego in check," he says, and credits defense work with giving him the vision to "understand where it can happen" [1]. From his own defense practice, he says innocent clients mostly turned up in domestic violence cases, where emotions run high and accusations come easily, and where the allegations sometimes did not match the injuries, noting that "it's so easy to get probable cause" [1].

Then Tomlinson experienced the other side himself. He admits the trouble started with his own mistake: a relationship with a woman in his roughly 100-person office, which became contentious; recordings of arguments were released, and he takes responsibility and says he has made amends with her [1]. But he says the real turning point was the Head Start exoneration, which angered police and former prosecutors, along with a feud with the county sheriff, whose department hired both the man Tomlinson had defeated and the man who would run against him [1]. On October 1, 2024, a month before the election, he and his chief of staff Jim Burge were charged by complaint, with no grand jury, with tampering with records, intimidation and bribery [1]. He says three days after the charges the woman texted the detective that the charges were false, but those exculpatory messages were not turned over until November 7, two days after he lost; the charges were dropped shortly afterward [1]. He also claims the lead detective was trying to sleep with her during the investigation [1]. Rogan and Dubin compare the human cost of such politically driven prosecutions to what Trump faced on a national scale [1].

Finally, Tomlinson watched his own decision on the Ohio 4 get undone. With his term ending on January 6, he and the defense filed a joint motion for new trials, planning to dismiss the charges once it was granted [1]. Dubin says in 24 years he had never seen a judge do anything but hold a hearing on such a motion; instead the judges were silent [1]. The incoming prosecutor, Tony Cillo, had worked in that office and was, in Tomlinson's words, in a mentor-protégé relationship with the original assistant prosecutor; he told the local paper he didn't understand the rush [1]. Ohio's attorney general, Cillo's former employer, filed a brief asking the court to wait [1]. Judge Chris Cook first rejected that request, writing that pausing a case for a new official was "not how the system operates" [1]. Three days later the same judge rejected the defense's emergency motion, writing that "no rational person will conclude that a change in county prosecutor constitutes an emergency," and cited Tomlinson's own Head Start exoneration to argue that a new prosecutor can revisit a predecessor's decisions [1]. Another judge denied Cleveland's motion without a hearing, and on his second day in office Cillo withdrew the state's support [1].

Dubin adds a coda: he found a document showing that alternative suspects were once reported to the prosecutor's office and assigned to Cillo to investigate, including one whose ex-wife said he was cleaning bloody clothes the night of the murder [1]. He publicly invited Cillo to make their upcoming March 18 meeting public and present any evidence of guilt [1].

Notably, Tomlinson is not an anti-police reformer. He calls himself pro-police and says "I trust police much more than I almost do prosecutors," because officers seem to want to get it right while prosecutors want to win [1]. He handled about ten fatal police shootings, found every one justified, and ruled on them himself instead of hiding behind a grand jury [1]. His critique is aimed at the incentives of the prosecutor's chair specifically.

Joe Rogan: the urge to win

Rogan's contribution across these episodes is a theory of motive. In the Dubin and Tomlinson conversation he argues the root problem is the human drive to win: people cheat at pool and cards, and the same instinct in the legal system produces wrongful prosecutions [1]. In his words, people "want to win. They're playing a game, and they're in a system, and the system rewards success," and when "something falls apart and it looks bad," a "career doesn't progress" [1]. He points to videos of police planting guns as proof "it fucking happens" [1].

His structural idea is an independent panel of attorneys, "No financial ties no no ties to anybody that's a part of any of it," whose job would be "to review things and make sure there's no bias" before a case goes to court [1]. Dubin's reply, that this is what the grand jury was supposed to be, is itself a sign of how far the existing check has drifted from its purpose [1].

Rogan also brings in the context of circumstance. When Dubin notes that the Ohio 4 men admit they were selling drugs, Rogan says that doesn't make them murderers, and that people raised amid crime "imitate your atmosphere" [1]. He notes, too, that resources shape outcomes: "what eight million dollars can do is pretty extraordinary," he says of the O.J. Simpson defense, while "a lot of these guys get charged with crimes. They kind of get usher through the system" [1].

Rod Blagojevich: "The side that's hiding is the side that's lying"

Rod Blagojevich, the former two-term Democratic governor of Illinois, was arrested in 2008, removed from office, convicted of corruption and sentenced to 14 years; he served nearly eight before President Trump commuted his sentence in 2020 [2]. His is a one-sided account, and the episode gives him a long platform to tell it [2]. What he describes fits the same pattern from another angle: prosecutors so invested in a target that they would not let evidence cut against their case.

He says federal authorities began investigating his administration in December 2003, ten months after he took office, and pursued him for five years before wiretapping his phones in late October 2008 [2]. "I never imagined that the FBI and that Department of Justice and these US attorneys who come out of the best schools would be so corrupt and dishonest," he says [2]. He insists the talk over Barack Obama's vacated Senate seat was legal political horse-trading, admits his infamous line about the seat being golden, and says no one alleged he took a penny [2]. His claim is that prosecutors, having invested five years and "came up with nothing," built crimes out of those conversations [2].

The heart of his complaint is hidden evidence. He says prosecutors played only about 2% of the recordings at trial and a court seal still keeps him from releasing the rest [2]. "The side that refuses to play 98% of the tapes that they made. Or the guy that's saying play them all," he asks. "What are you hiding? The side that's hiding is the side that's lying. And they're hiding it to this day." [2] He says his judge promised he could play tapes to corroborate his testimony about a pending deal with House Speaker Michael Madigan, then barred them after he testified, and prosecutors told the jury to "see how many times he talked about the Madigan deal" [2]. "Even though there were 102 conversations on that subject, they were all covered up and the jury didn't know those tapes existed. It was a total fucking frame up. In a rigged criminal justice system, in a court that was rigged." [2]

He also describes pressure on others. He says businessman Tony Rezko was squeezed to implicate him and Obama: "They put him into solitary confinement for three years to get him to invent crimes against us. He wouldn't do it." [2] After a first trial failed to convict him, he says prosecutors floated an 18-month deal and later sought 30 years to life [2]. He believes he spent nearly three years in a higher-security prison as punishment for refusing to plead guilty [2]. That escalation, from offering a small deal to seeking decades after a defendant refuses, is the incentive structure from the defendant's side: fighting back raises the price.

On motive, Blagojevich believes Patrick Fitzgerald wanted to convict a second straight Illinois governor, and connects Fitzgerald and James Comey to what he sees as the later weaponization against Trump [2]. Of prosecutors he says, "They're supposed to do justice," and "They're not supposed to be a political power center" [2]; the conversation describes the game as "a lot of moves and counter moves" [2]. Rogan agrees on the danger, calling the weaponizing of the justice system against Trump "such an insanely dangerous precedent to set" [2]. Later the two sum up the justice system this way: "It's a dangerous system, especially the justice system. It seems very dangerous," and "Absolute power corrupts, absolutely." [2]

Blagojevich's other example of unaccountability is Andrew Weissmann's prosecution of Arthur Andersen: the Supreme Court "ruled nine to nothing unanimous that the standard that Weissman used to prosecute Arthur Anderson was an unlawful standard," but only after the firm had already collapsed [2]. His prescription is explicit accountability: to send "a message to these unaccountable prosecutors who have no check in ballots that if they do this and frame innocent people, they're going to be treated the same way as a dirty cop of plants of murder weapon to frame an innocent man" [2]. He frames this as justice, "not to be vengeful" [2].

He also explains why the cost of distrust is systemic, not personal. Discussing dirty cops who were rightly prosecuted, he says: "But what if you don't trust those prosecutors? Right? Suddenly the whole system breaks down. You can't trust anything." [2] And he describes the social side of being on the wrong end: "All your friends and politics, they run for the hills, they abandon you" [2].

Importantly, Blagojevich does not say everyone in prison is innocent. He says most men he served with were guilty, and that the bigger injustice is over-sentencing under one-size-fits-all guidelines that ignore a person's background, citing Alice Marie Johnson's life sentence for a first-time nonviolent drug offense and blaming the 1994 crime bill [2]. He says the system needs "mercy and redemption" [2]. He is also candid that he still hates the people who did this to him, admitting he is "not that good a Christian" [2].

Get new summaries by email

The GIST of every new summary in your inbox, daily or weekly. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.

Joe Rogan and Woody Harrelson: Kids for Cash and following the money

The third conversation adds the bluntest version of the incentive problem: a judge paid to lock children up. It comes up in the Woody Harrelson episode, but the story is told by Rogan, while praising Dubin's work [3]. Rogan describes Dubin as "completely dedicated his life to wrongly incarcerated people," concentrating on cases involving "corrupt DAs, corrupt prosecutors, corrupt judges. It's like, you know, it's all over the place" [3]. Then he brings up the Pennsylvania case: "There was a judge in Pennsylvania that was making millions of dollars through putting kids in detention centers and ruining kids' lives, causing suicides, deaths, downward spiral of their life, like wrongfully detaining them and doing it for profit." [3] Asked how the judge got paid, Rogan says, "He's getting kickbacks, getting kickbacks from private prisons," adding, "I don't know exactly who was funding it, but he was convicted" [3]. Rogan also says one of the people involved was among those Biden pardoned, which he calls "sick" [3].

Rogan's take on pardons is not simple, though. He says "generally I'm a fan of pardoning people," because "I think most people are incarcerated for far too long. I don't think it rehabilitates people" [3]. His objection is to who got the mercy, not to mercy itself.

The episode's broader theme is that money distorts institutions. Harrelson says his Saturday Night Live monologue was "really about profiteering," and Rogan calls profiting off everything "the dirtiest aspect of human beings" [3]. In one of their lines, "if war weren't so lucrative, there'd be a lot less of it" [3]. Rogan ties drug laws to private prisons and prison guard unions that profit from incarceration, and Harrelson says the documentary 13th first made him see prison labor as a form of slavery [3]: "Slave labor for insanely small amount of money And they keep them locked up and they produce things" [3]. Harrelson also argues for the principle of victimless crime: "Anything I do that hurts you or your property. Otherwise, there's no crime." [3] He shares that his daughter is a public defender in Manhattan [3].

The episode also brings up Freeway Rick Ross, who, as Rogan tells it, learned to read in prison, taught himself law and won his release, the same figure Rogan recommends Blagojevich learn from [3][2].

Where They Agree, and Where They Don't

Agreement

All three conversations agree that the system's errors are not random: they come from incentives that reward winning and protect the people who make mistakes [1][2][3]. Dubin says prosecutors have immunity and no consequences for withholding exculpatory evidence [1]; Blagojevich calls them "unaccountable prosecutors who have no check in ballots" [2]; Rogan describes a system that "rewards success" and punishes careers when a case falls apart [1], and in the Harrelson episode points to a judge paid by private prisons [3].

They agree that hidden evidence is the mechanism that most often turns an error into a wrongful outcome. In the Ohio 4 case, the Secret Service's warning about Avery Jr. did not stop the trials [1]; in Tomlinson's own case, exculpatory texts surfaced two days after he lost his election [1]; Blagojevich says 98% of the tapes were never played and that the jury "didn't know those tapes existed" [2].

They agree on accountability as the remedy. Dubin calls it "an easier fix" than restructuring grand juries [1]; Blagojevich wants prosecutors who frame people treated like "a dirty cop" who plants evidence [2]. Rogan backs the idea of independent review [1] and agrees people who make bad choices should not be thrown away [2].

They also agree on the value of mercy and on the harm of overlong sentences. Blagojevich asks for "mercy and redemption" [2]; Rogan thinks "most people are incarcerated for far too long" [3]; Tomlinson's apology to Nancy Smith and Joseph Allen and his push to get them compensated put that into practice [1].

And they agree that ordinary goodwill exists inside the system. Tomlinson says the system works "most of the time" [1]; Rogan, in the Blagojevich episode, says he has met great people in the FBI and CIA [2]; Dubin has come to see prosecutors and police who care as much as he does [1].

Disagreement and differences in emphasis

The biggest difference is about whether the problem is corruption or ordinary human failing. Blagojevich uses the strongest language: "corrupt and dishonest," "a total fucking frame up," "a court that was rigged" [2]. Dubin and Tomlinson mostly describe something less deliberate: ego, loyalty and the difficulty of saying I was wrong [1]. Tomlinson even defends the system as working most of the time [1]. The Kids for Cash story, as Rogan tells it, sits at the corrupt end: a judge taking kickbacks [3]. Each side's view follows from its experience: Blagojevich was the defendant and sees intent; Tomlinson was the prosecutor and sees how easy it is for "the stuff to happen" without anyone planning it [1][2].

They also differ on where to put trust. Tomlinson trusts police more than prosecutors, because officers want to get it right while prosecutors want to win [1]. Blagojevich's anger is aimed at the FBI and US attorneys together [2], though he agrees that dirty cops should be prosecuted and that the problem comes when people cannot trust the prosecutors themselves [2]. Rogan in the Dubin episode both notes cops planting guns [1] and argues that viral clips create a skewed picture of police, since the vast majority of encounters are positive [1].

There is a quiet disagreement about the fixes. Rogan wants an independent review panel [1]; Dubin thinks that is as hard as moving a mountain and pushes accountability instead [1]; Tomlinson favors requiring defense experience for prosecutors and voting in local elections [1]; Blagojevich looks to the new federal leadership to hold prosecutors to account [2]. These are not contradictory, but they reflect different beliefs about whether the fix is structural, personal or political.

Finally, the reliability of the accounts differs. The Ohio 4 case, as Dubin and Tomlinson present it, is backed by a federal appeals court's written finding of a "credible claim of actual innocence" and by the recantations [1]. Blagojevich's account is his own; the summary notes that the episode gives him a long platform to tell his side, and he himself labels one idea, about Rahm Emanuel, as a theory [2]. Readers should weigh his claims as a defendant's case, not a finding. The Kids for Cash story is told in passing by Rogan, who admits "I don't know exactly who was funding it" [3].

Why It Works

The sources describe several mechanisms that keep mistakes in place.

Winning is rewarded; losing is punished. Rogan's argument is that the justice system is a game with scores, where "the system rewards success" and a case that falls apart hurts a career [1]. Tomlinson draws the same line between police who want to get it right and prosecutors who want to win [1]. Once a conviction is a win, reopening it is a loss.

Immunity removes the downside. Dubin says the one consequence that could change behavior is missing: "prosecutors have immunity There are no consequences," even when exculpatory evidence is withheld [1]. Blagojevich makes the same point through the Arthur Andersen case: the prosecution's standard was ruled unlawful 9-0, but the company had already collapsed, and he describes no penalty for the prosecutor, who went on to be a legal expert at CNN [2].

The checks are one-sided. The grand jury was meant to filter weak cases, but the defense cannot be in the room and the standard is low, hence "you can indict a ham sandwich" [1]. Tomlinson himself was charged by complaint with no grand jury at all [1]. And probable cause, in Tomlinson's words, "is very easy" [1].

Controlling the evidence controls the story. In each case, the decisive evidence was held by one side. The Secret Service's warning about Avery Jr. went to the lead prosecutor [1]; the exculpatory texts in Tomlinson's case came out after the election [1]; Blagojevich says the 102 Madigan conversations were sealed while the prosecution argued they did not exist [2].

Loyalty and ego protect predecessors. The Ohio 4 reversal came from a successor with a mentor-protégé relationship to the original trial prosecutor, backed by an attorney general who was his former employer [1]. Admitting the conviction was wrong would mean admitting a mentor's error. Tomlinson's rare apology stands out precisely because, as the Innocence Project lawyer told him, prosecutors don't do it [1].

Punishment for fighting back. Blagojevich describes an 18-month offer that became a request for 30 years to life after he went to trial, and time in a higher-security prison he attributes to refusing to plead guilty [2]. Tomlinson says he was charged after exonerating Smith and Allen angered police and former prosecutors [1]. Avery Jr. was warned about perjury and stayed silent [1]. When telling the truth or challenging the office carries a price, errors stay buried.

Money. The starkest mechanism is direct payment: the Ohio 4 case began with a $2,500 reward to a paid informant [1], and the Kids for Cash judge was "getting kickbacks from private prisons" [3]. Rogan and Harrelson trace the same logic through private prisons and prison labor [3].

Politics. Blagojevich argues prosecutors are "not supposed to be a political power center" but act like one [2]; Tomlinson describes charges filed 30 days before his re-election [1]; Rogan and Dubin compare it to what Trump faced [1]. Where a prosecution is a political weapon, admitting it was wrong is a political loss too.

Where It Applies, and Where It Doesn't

Where it applies. The pattern is strongest where one actor controls both the evidence and the decision whether to revisit the case, as a county prosecutor does [1]. It applies to cases built on a single paid or pressured witness [1], to cases where the defendant cannot afford a strong defense ("what eight million dollars can do is pretty extraordinary," as Rogan says of O.J. Simpson's) [1], and to politically charged prosecutions at the local and federal level [1][2]. It applies wherever someone is paid for the outcome, from informant rewards to private-prison kickbacks [1][3]. It also applies after conviction: the Ohio 4 men were still in prison decades later despite a federal court's finding [1].

Where it doesn't. The guests themselves limit the claim. Tomlinson says the system "works most of the time" [1]. Blagojevich says most of the men he served with were guilty, and that his broader complaint about others is over-sentencing rather than innocence [2]. Tomlinson found all ten fatal police shootings he reviewed justified [1], and Rogan argues most police encounters are positive [1]. And the pattern is not universal among prosecutors: Tomlinson himself reviewed cases, apologized in court and moved to free people [1], and Judge Cook at first refused to pause the case for the new official [1]. The incentives make admitting error hard, not impossible.

The strength of the evidence also varies. The Ohio 4 account rests on a documented recantation, an affidavit and a federal court's finding [1]. Blagojevich's account is a convicted defendant's version, including claims he cannot fully back up because, he says, the tapes remain sealed [2]. The Kids for Cash story is told briefly, with Rogan himself unsure of the funding details [3]. The pattern holds across all three, but readers should weigh each piece accordingly.

What To Do With It

  1. Vote in local races, especially for county prosecutor. Tomlinson's advice is to "vote local," because the county prosecutor has far more power over your life than the president [1]. The Ohio 4 case turned on who held that office on January 6 [1].

  2. Look for prosecutors with defense experience. Tomlinson credits 15 years of defense work with showing him "how easy it is" for wrongful convictions to happen, and proposes making it a requirement [1]. When choosing candidates, ask whether they have sat on that side of the courtroom.

  3. Support accountability for withheld evidence. Dubin's "easier fix" is ending the absence of consequences for prosecutors who don't turn over exculpatory evidence [1]; Blagojevich wants those who frame people treated like dirty cops [2]. Backing reforms along these lines targets the incentive, not just individual cases.

  4. Be skeptical of cases built on paid or pressured witnesses. The Ohio 4 case rested on an informant who responded to a $2,500 reward, demanded $10,000, admitted he made it up and was dropped by the Secret Service for taking money for false information [1]. When one paid witness carries a case, ask what else supports it.

  5. Ask what evidence has not been shown. Blagojevich's rule of thumb, "The side that's hiding is the side that's lying," is his argument, not a legal standard [2], but the question behind it is useful: in both Ohio cases and his own, the decisive evidence was held back [1][2].

  6. If you are under investigation, get a lawyer before talking. Blagojevich's advice to anyone chased by the FBI is simply not to talk to them [2]. Given how easy probable cause is to establish, as Tomlinson says [1], talk to a qualified criminal defense attorney before you say anything.

  7. Praise and protect the officials who admit mistakes. Tomlinson's apology to Smith and Allen was so rare an Innocence Project lawyer had never heard one, and his exoneration work made him enemies [1]. If admitting error costs officials their careers, fewer will do it; public support changes that calculation.

  8. Practice the same humility yourself. Dubin's fix begins with being able to say "I made a mistake," as he learned mid-argument with his wife [1]; Tomlinson tries to put his "ego in check" and admit when he doesn't know [1]. Dubin's own resolution after upsetting a corrections officer friend was to be "quicker to listen and slower to speak" [1].

  9. Follow the money in any case you are judging. The Kids for Cash judge was paid by private prisons [3]; the Ohio 4 case began with a reward [1]. Rogan and Harrelson's recurring advice is to look for who profits [3].

  10. Support organizations and advocates who reopen cases. Rogan points to Dubin's work, which through the podcast has helped get "a bunch of people released" [3], and Dubin directs people to his Free the Ohio 4 website, where he posted his submission to Tomlinson and all its exhibits [1]. Public attention, as the Ohio 4 story shows, can be what gets a prosecutor to pick up the phone [1].

Sources

  1. 2287 – Josh Dubin & J.D. Tomlinson · The Joe Rogan Experience
  2. Rod Blagojevich · The Joe Rogan Experience
  3. Woody Harrelson · The Joe Rogan Experience

Products and resources from this insight

Some of these are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Perfect Summary is paid a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Perfect Summary earns from qualifying purchases.

  • Caste · Isabel Wilkerson
    Dubin recommends it for understanding the Black American experience
  • Man's Search for Meaning · Viktor Frankl(our summary)
    Blagojevich read it three times in prison to find his purpose
  • The New Jim Crow · Michelle Alexander
    Cited by Blagojevich on mass incarceration's impact on Black Americans
  • The Real Anthony Fauci · Robert F. Kennedy Jr.(our summary)
    Both praise it; Harrelson wanted to hand it to Neil Young
  • The Sacred Mushroom and the Cross · John Marco Allegro(our summary)
    Rogan recommends it on psychedelic origins of religion
  • The Immortality Key · Brian Muraresku(our summary)
    Rogan recommends it on ergot and the Eleusinian mysteries
  • Defense Soap · Defense Soap
    Natural soap Rogan uses daily to prevent grappling skin infections

Read next

Report a problem

Something wrong on this page? A mistake, a broken link, audio that won't play? Tell us and we'll fix it.