Insight | Meditation, hypnosis or NSDR? Choosing a calming practice
Huberman explains how to choose a meditation that runs against your attention bias and how NSDR differs from meditation, David Spiegel describes clinical hypnosis for stress and sleep, and Elissa Epel links meditation to telomeres and mitochondria. Several evidence-based practices exist, and fit with your temperament determines which one you'll actually keep.

The Short Version
Meditation, clinical hypnosis and non-sleep deep rest (NSDR) are different tools that do different jobs. Choose by goal and by temperament, not by which one is fashionable. Andrew Huberman treats meditation as training in refocusing attention. He says the best kind is the one that runs against your current bias, and he points to NSDR or yoga nidra, not meditation, when the goal is sleep or recovery [1][2]. David Spiegel describes hypnosis as "a state of highly focused attention" that lets people cut stress, pain and sleeplessness in a few sessions, but it works best for the roughly two-thirds of adults who are hypnotizable at all [3]. Elissa Epel links meditation to slower cellular aging through telomeres and mitochondria. Her breathwork trial found that stress, anxiety and depression fell in every group it tested, which suggests there are many roads to relief [4]. Across these sources, the practice that works is one that fits your goal, your nervous system and your willingness to keep doing it.
Table of contents
What They Said
Andrew Huberman: meditation is several tools, so pick the one that fits
Huberman opens by warning against treating meditation as one thing. It is like exercise, which includes lifting, running and intervals, each with different results [1]. "Meditation is powerful, but you want to make sure that you pick the right meditation practice," he says. He means "picking a meditation practice that isn't just feasible because you'll do it, but is actually directed at the goal specific to you and what you need most." [1] He breaks practice into three adjustable parts: where you put your attention, how you breathe, and where you sit on a range from feeling everything to checking out [1].
Attention: inside or outside the body. Huberman describes perception as spotlights that can be narrow or broad and turned up or down [1]. Interoception is sensing from the skin inward: heartbeat, breath, stomach, temperature. Exteroception is perceiving everything outside the body [1]. Simply closing your eyes produces "a massive shift" toward interoception, because vision takes up 40 percent or more of the brain [1]. Neither end is good in itself. Anxious people are often acutely aware of every change in heart rate or breathing, while people with little interoceptive awareness may miss warning signs [1]. As he puts it, the clinical literature says "interoceptive awareness is terrific, except for the person that is so aware of their internal functioning that they are not able to engage in the world." [1]
Why presence matters. He cites a 2010 paper by Matthew Killingsworth and Dan Gilbert that pinged more than 2,200 adults on their phones. Their minds wandered in nearly half of the samples, and people were less happy when their minds wandered, even when the thoughts were pleasant [1]. The authors concluded that "a human mind is a wandering mind. And a wandering mind is an unhappy mind." Thinking about what isn't happening "is a cognitive achievement that comes at an emotional cost." [1] Meditation trains presence, and presence is one of the strongest predictors of happiness [1].
The central rule: go against your bias. Before meditating, sit, close your eyes and notice whether your attention stays inside easily or keeps getting pulled out. Then open your eyes and check how well you can focus outward [1]. This is not a personality test, just a check of where you are right now. If you're stuck in your head or looping on thoughts, do an exteroceptive practice: fix your gaze on a point on the wall, a plant or the horizon. If you're scattered by your surroundings, like in a busy airport, do an interoceptive practice focused on the breath or the spot behind your forehead [1]. "Just do the opposite of where your bias lies." [1]
He warns that meditation isn't automatically good. A very interoceptive person may get worse with inward-focused meditation, and someone disconnected from their feelings may drift further away with outward practice [1]. The deeper reason to go against your bias is neuroplasticity. His graduate advisor used to say of difficulty, "that means you're learning," and "challenge and discomfort is the signal to your brain" that something needs to change [1]. Drawing on the book Altered Traits, he treats meditation as a refocusing practice. Expert meditators aren't locked in unwavering focus. They leave and return to focus faster [1]. So "think about your ability to refocus" rather than your ability to focus [1].
Why the "third eye" can backfire. The spot behind the forehead that meditators focus on is really the prefrontal cortex, not the pineal gland [1]. The brain has no sensory neurons. When you place attention where there's nothing to feel, thoughts, emotions and memories come flooding up [1]. That's why third-eye meditation can feel like a rush of disorganized thoughts. Paradoxically, the best way to quiet thinking is often to focus on a sensation or something outside you [1].
Breathing as a lever. Decide before each session whether you want to leave more alert or more relaxed [1]. Inhales that are longer or stronger than exhales shift you toward alertness. Longer or stronger exhales shift you toward calm. Balanced breaths, like box breathing, keep you where you are [1][2]. Deliberate breathing pulls attention inward: "an interoceptive, biased breath work practice will have a specific effect, which is to make you more interoceptively aware." [1] Simple rhythmic breathing can run in the background, while complex patterns like double inhales demand attention [1]. His recipe: to get out of your head, pair an outward focus with natural breathing. To come back into your body, use a deliberate, unusual breathing pattern [1].
The dissociation dimension. With Stanford psychiatrist David Spiegel, Huberman is formalizing a second range, from interoception to dissociation [1]. "Again, dissociation isn't always bad, provided it's not at the extreme." A mild form, the "narrative distancing" that keeps you from feeling hit when someone in a movie is hit, is adaptive [1]. His model pictures your state as a ball bearing on a track. Sleep, exercise, therapy, journaling, social connection and meditation curl up the edges of the track to keep you near the middle. Sleep deprivation flattens it, so you tip into being overwhelmed or checked out [1].
How long and how often. Getting better at meditation means you can drop into the state faster and may need less time, not more. "The more that you can get into specific neural circuits quickly, actually the less you need to meditate in order to drive the benefits of meditation." [1] He cites Wendy Suzuki's NYU study, in which 13 minutes of daily meditation for about eight weeks improved mood, attention, memory, emotional regulation and sleep compared with a control group that listened to a podcast [1]. His own lab has seen benefits for stress and sleep with five minutes a day, and he suggests three minutes as a realistic starting point [1]. "Consistency is key," so pick what you will actually do. If that's only once a week, go longer, perhaps 10 to 30 minutes [1]. He credits the Waking Up app with giving him his most consistent practice, partly because it briefly explains what each meditation does [1].
Huberman on NSDR: the tool for sleep and recovery
In Suzuki's study, meditating too close to bedtime made it harder to fall asleep [1]. That makes sense, because meditation is a focusing practice and sleep requires letting go of focus [1]. At his live Q&A, Huberman described meditation as mainly strengthening attention, cognitive control and memory. It can be stimulating and is best done earlier in the day [2].
He also takes on the claim that meditation can replace sleep. Some studies of two 20-minute sessions a day suggest the drop in stress and cortisol helps people function on less sleep, but "Those results are debated." [1] The idea that you can skip a night and just meditate the next day: "Certainly that is not supported by the literature." [1]
For sleep he turns to yoga nidra and NSDR. These are "anti-focus" body-scan practices [1], "focusing on the sensation of the body and actually trying to turn off that prefrontal cortex or reduce its activity." [1] He cites a randomized trial in people with chronic insomnia in which yoga nidra improved sleep and significantly lowered salivary cortisol, and a Scandinavian study in which 30 minutes of yoga nidra replenished dopamine [1]. By his reading, these practices restore dopamine and reduce cortisol "At least as much and by my read of the literature significantly more than with traditional meditation." [1] He acknowledges that yoga nidra "has been around for thousands of years and was certainly there before NSDR." [1] His 10-minute NSDR script is free on YouTube, and all of this is "completely zero cost." [1]
At the Q&A he added that NSDR works fast and doesn't require extensive training or skill. It restores mental clarity, reduces anxiety, boosts dopamine and improves sleep quality [2]. His one-line split: "third eye meditation can be very relaxing, and yet it's a focus and refocus practice," while yoga nidra and NSDR are about "replenishing yourself, replacing sleep that you've lost or maybe even reducing your sleep need." [1] In short, use NSDR or yoga nidra to recover and sleep better, and meditation to improve focus, mood and deliberate control of attention [1].
Where hypnosis fits. Huberman says "hypnosis is distinct from breathwork, from yoga, needra, from NSTR and from meditation. Even though it includes some of those components, like focusing your attention, it involves actually directing your visual attention outward than inward." [1] He describes clinical hypnosis as targeting specific problems, and says it has been shown to substantially boost smoking cessation compared with going cold turkey [1]. At the Q&A he said hypnosis combines alertness and relaxation in a way that suits rapid neuroplasticity, and that he practices self-directed hypnosis regularly to manage emotions and reduce stress [2].
David Spiegel: clinical hypnosis as focused, trainable control
Spiegel, associate chair of psychiatry at Stanford, starts by removing the stage-show image. "Hypnosis is a state of highly focused attention," like looking through a telephoto lens: great detail but little context [3]. Getting so absorbed in a movie that you forget you're in the audience is a hypnotic-like experience many people have every day [3]. He dislikes stage hypnosis ("You're making fools out of people") [3]. He says people fear hypnosis because they think they lose control, but "They think you're losing control. You're gaining control." [3]
What changes in the brain. His lab's fMRI studies found three changes [3]. First, activity drops in the dorsal anterior cingulate cortex, part of the salience network that detects conflict and danger, so you're less likely to be pulled out of your focus. Second, the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex becomes more connected to the insula, a mind-body control area. Third, the prefrontal cortex becomes inversely connected with the posterior cingulate cortex, part of the default mode network tied to self-reflection. That lets people act without worrying about what it means for them, which adds flexibility [3]. More hypnotizable people also show more calming GABA activity in the anterior cingulate [3]. The mind-body link is striking. Hypnotized people who imagined eating their favorite foods raised their stomach acid secretion by 87 percent. When they relaxed and thought of anything but food, it dropped by about 40 percent [3].
For stress. Spiegel says stress often snowballs: you notice your body tensing, decide it's really bad, and feel worse [3]. His technique separates the physical reaction from the worry. Imagine your body floating somewhere safe and comfortable, like a bath, a lake or space. Picture the problem on an imaginary screen, with the rule that whatever you see, your body stays comfortable. Then use the screen to think through one thing you might do about it [3].
For sleep. If you wake at night, don't look at the clock, which is an arousal cue. Instead, watch your worries on the screen while your body keeps floating [3]. He says he gets emails from people who hadn't slept well in 15 years and now can [3].
For pain and procedures. In a randomized trial published in The Lancet, patients having uncomfortable procedures without general anesthesia who learned self-hypnosis had reduced their pain by 80 percent compared with standard care about an hour and a half in. They used half the opioids, had fewer complications and no anxiety, and their procedures took 17 minutes less [3]. "If we had a drug that did that every hospital in the country would be using it now," he says, but no industry is pushing it [3]. In women with metastatic breast cancer who met weekly in support groups and learned self-hypnosis, the treatment group had half the pain of the control group after a year [3]. Children who learned self-hypnosis before a difficult bladder imaging procedure were less anxious, felt less pain and finished 17 minutes faster [3].
For trauma, and why control matters. "The essence of trauma is helplessness it's not fear it's not pain it's helplessness." [3] Self-hypnosis is something you make happen and can switch on and off, so it restores a sense of control [3]. A randomized trial from Israel found that adding hypnosis to PTSD treatment improved outcomes [3]. Spiegel even says, "I'm not a big fan of trigger warnings." What matters is feeling in control of how you approach upsetting material [3].
Who it works for. This is the key point for choosing. Hypnotizability is a stable trait. "Every eight-year-old is in a trance all the time," but by the early twenties it is largely fixed, with a test-retest correlation of about 0.7 over 25 years, more stable than IQ [3]. About a third of adults are not hypnotizable, and about 15 percent are extremely hypnotizable [3]. Training raises scores only a little, and he says it isn't worth the effort [3]. For low scorers he uses other approaches, such as medication or mindfulness [3]. People with OCD tend to be less hypnotizable because they are busy evaluating rather than experiencing. He also suspects many people with ADHD are not very hypnotizable, though he hasn't studied it [3].
His quick screen is the eye-roll test. Tilt your head back, look up toward the ceiling and slowly close your eyelids. If mostly the whites of your eyes show, you're likely more hypnotizable. If the colored iris shows as the lids come down, less so [3]. Looking up and closing your eyes while staying alert signals the brain to turn inward [3].
How to start. Hypnosis works because it becomes a skill, and people can tell quickly whether it helps [3]. Spiegel often sees patients only once or twice. He tests them, guides them through an exercise for their problem, and teaches them to do it alone [3]. The Reveri app, which he helped develop, offers 15-minute sessions and one- to two-minute refreshers. He says two-thirds of users find it helpful even at one minute [3]. For clinicians, he points to the Society for Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis and the American Society of Clinical Hypnosis. He recommends someone licensed in their primary discipline, since a symptom like chest pain needs a proper diagnosis first [3]. His breathing research with Huberman on cyclic sighing, which stresses long exhales, led him to emphasize a slow exhale during his inductions [3].
The GIST of every new summary in your inbox, daily or weekly. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.
Elissa Epel: meditation and the biology of aging, plus many paths to calm
Epel, a UCSF psychiatry professor, studies how stress gets under the skin [4]. She defines stress as feeling that demands exceed your resources. The modern problem is keeping the stress response alive long after the event, and in her words our thoughts are the most common form of stress [4].
Meditation and telomeres. Meditators tend to show slower biological aging [4]. Short-term meditation training dampens inflammatory gene expression and boosts telomerase, the enzyme that rebuilds telomeres. Work by Elizabeth Hoge found longer telomeres in long-term meditators [4]. Epel's team compared a week-long meditation retreat with a group that simply vacationed at the same resort. Everyone felt great after a week, but ten months later only the meditation group still had lower depression, and people with early adversity benefited most [4]. She recommends working up gradually to longer silent retreats, but stresses that short daily practices matter most for everyday stress [4].
Mitochondria and evening mood. With Martin Picard, Epel measured mitochondrial health in blood. Mothers caring for children with autism had markedly lower mitochondrial activity than mothers of neurotypical children [4]. Across caregivers, those with healthier mitochondria reported more positive emotion, especially in the evening [4]. Evening mood matters. People who can find some ease or joy at the end of a stressful day tend to have less depression, heart disease and early death a decade later [4]. The stress response is energetically expensive and draws on ATP made by mitochondria, which helps explain why constant vigilance leaves people exhausted [4].
Body scans. Epel cites a study in which overweight people with strong cravings significantly reduced them with a body scan: moving attention slowly from head to toe, breathing into each area and releasing tension [4]. She advises that everyone do some form of body scan or mind-body practice [4]. In her pregnancy trial, the practice was a mindful check-in with eyes closed and emotions labeled, slow breathing with hands on the belly, then movement such as prenatal yoga or walking [4]. Half as many women in the mindfulness group developed impaired glucose tolerance, and their mental health stayed better every year for eight years. Epel calls it one of the longest studies of mindfulness effects [4].
Three buckets, and her own preference. Epel sorts stress tools into top-down strategies (awareness, beliefs, mindset), body-based strategies (exercise, breathing, movement) and changing the scene [4]. Of the body-based ones she says they're concrete they're quick they're also my favorite strategies. [4] When she wakes "super jittery with a big stress response," her biggest payoff comes from "something like a hits type workout or taking the dogs for like a really brisk walk." She adds that "everyone has their you know different ways that they can see the biggest shifts in daily stress." [4] She and Huberman agree that breathing is the most direct and fastest way to reduce stress in the body [4].
The breathwork trial. After doing Wim Hof breathing with Hof himself at a conference, "I just felt like elation afterward," Epel launched a study with Wendy Mendes and Aric Prather [4]. Participants practiced daily for three weeks and were randomly assigned to low-arousal methods (mindfulness, slow breathing) or high-arousal positive stress (aerobic exercise or the Wim Hof method) [4]. Stress, anxiety and depression fell dramatically in every group, which suggests many paths to relief. The Wim Hof method alone increased daily positive emotion over time [4].
Muscle or release. Epel's broader frame is flexibility: "you muscle it and or you release it and we need both." [4] She describes "skillful surfing" between life's waves, knowing when to push and when to let go [4]. She and Huberman conclude that we can't reduce stress with a drug. We have to learn to use the full range of our nervous system, from activation to deep rest [4].
Where They Agree, and Where They Don't
They agree there is no single best practice. Huberman says meditation is many tools that give different results [1]. Spiegel uses hypnosis for hypnotizable people and other approaches for low scorers [3]. Epel's trial found relief in every arm, and she notes that everyone has their own way to the biggest shifts [4].
They agree that consistency and brevity count. Huberman suggests starting at three minutes and says "Consistency is key." [1] Spiegel's patients use one- to two-minute refreshers, and most find even one minute helpful [3]. Epel says short daily practice matters most for everyday stress [4].
They agree on long, slow exhales for calm. Huberman's rule [1][2], Spiegel's inductions [3] and Epel's view of breathing as the fastest lever [4] line up.
They agree that sleep needs a different tool than focus. Huberman separates focus-based meditation, which can delay sleep if done at night, from NSDR and yoga nidra [1][2]. Spiegel uses a floating-body, worry-on-a-screen routine for night waking [3]. Neither offers focus meditation as the answer at 3 a.m.
They differ on how NSDR compares to meditation. Huberman reads the literature as showing that yoga nidra and NSDR restore dopamine and reduce cortisol "significantly more than with traditional meditation." [1] He also notes that fewer studies exist on them than on meditation [1]. Epel, meanwhile, points to meditation's long-term effects on telomerase, inflammatory genes and depression ten months later, evidence NSDR doesn't have in these sources [4]. The difference comes from what each is measuring. Huberman looks at quick recovery and sleep. Epel looks at long-term cellular aging.
They differ on whether hypnosis points attention inward or outward. Huberman says hypnosis "involves actually directing your visual attention outward than inward." [1] Spiegel describes the eye-roll induction as signaling the brain to turn inward, and has patients picture problems on an internal screen while the body floats [3]. They are collaborators, so this may be a matter of emphasis. Hypnosis narrows attention like a telephoto lens [3], and where that lens points may vary. But on this point the sources don't match.
They differ on who a practice suits. Meditation and NSDR are presented as open to anyone, with NSDR requiring no skill [2]. Hypnosis comes with a gate: about a third of adults aren't hypnotizable, and training barely helps [3]. Epel's Wim Hof arm shows another dimension. High-arousal practice, not only calm practice, can build positive emotion [4].
Why It Works
Refocusing drives plasticity. Each time you notice your mind wandering and bring it back is a repetition. Difficulty is the signal for the brain to change [1]. That's why going against your bias trains you more than staying where you're comfortable [1].
Where you point attention changes what fills awareness. Closing your eyes shifts processing inward [1]. Focusing on a spot with no sensory neurons lets thoughts flood in [1]. An outward gaze or a body sensation gives attention something concrete, which can quiet thinking [1].
Breathing tips the balance between arousal and calm. Inhale-heavy breathing raises alertness and exhale-heavy breathing brings calm [1][2]. Spiegel builds slow exhales into inductions for that reason [3].
NSDR lowers the prefrontal cortex's grip. Yoga nidra and NSDR aim to reduce prefrontal activity through body scanning. Huberman links them to lower cortisol and replenished dopamine [1]. Meditation, by contrast, engages focus, which clashes with falling asleep [1].
Hypnosis quiets the alarm and loosens self-judgment. Lower activity in the salience network, a tighter link between prefrontal control and the insula, and a looser link with the self-reflective default mode network together let people stay absorbed, influence their bodies, and try new responses without worrying what it says about them [3]. The sense of control directly counters helplessness, which Spiegel sees as the core of trauma [3].
Meditation may slow cellular aging. Training reduces inflammatory gene expression and boosts telomerase [4]. Long-term meditators have longer telomeres [4]. Mitochondrial health tracks with positive evening mood in caregivers [4]. Reducing stress also produces a healthier daily cortisol pattern, which Huberman links to deeper sleep [1].
Where It Applies, and Where It Doesn't
Meditation fits focus, mood, attention control and long-term stress resilience, ideally earlier in the day [1][2][4]. It may not suit someone already overwhelmed by inner sensations if the practice is inward-focused, or someone disconnected from their feelings if it's outward-focused [1]. Meditating near bedtime can make falling asleep harder [1]. It doesn't replace a lost night of sleep [1].
NSDR and yoga nidra fit sleep problems, night waking, recovery after poor sleep, and quick resets during the day. They require no special skill [1][2]. The evidence base is smaller than for traditional meditation, as Huberman acknowledges [1].
Clinical hypnosis fits specific problems: stress spirals, insomnia, phobias, procedural and cancer pain, smoking and trauma, especially in hypnotizable people [1][3]. It suits children well, with more structure [3]. It is less likely to help people who aren't hypnotizable, and may help less for OCD and, Spiegel suspects, ADHD [3]. Symptoms like chest pain need a medical diagnosis before any hypnotic work [3].
High-arousal practices such as Wim Hof breathing or intense exercise fit people who, like Epel, get the biggest payoff from burning off stress energy [4]. Huberman treats cyclic hyperventilation as its own breathwork practice rather than meditation [1].
If you are dealing with trauma, insomnia, chronic pain or a mental health condition, work with a licensed clinician. Spiegel specifically recommends one trained in hypnosis and licensed in their own field [3].
What To Do With It
- Name your goal first. Decide whether you want better focus, calm, sleep, relief from a specific problem (pain, a phobia, smoking) or long-term stress resilience. Choose meditation for focus and mood, NSDR or yoga nidra for sleep and recovery, and clinical hypnosis for specific problems [1][2][3].
- Check your bias before you meditate. Close your eyes for a moment and notice whether your attention is stuck inside or pulled outward, then do the opposite. Look at a point on the wall or the horizon if you're in your head, and focus on the breath if you're scattered [1].
- Count refocusing as the win. Each return from wandering is a repetition. Judge progress by how fast you come back, not by how long you stay [1].
- Start small and be consistent. Begin with three to five minutes a day and work toward about 13 minutes, the dose in Suzuki's study. If you can only practice weekly, go 10 to 30 minutes [1].
- Keep focus meditation away from bedtime. Do it earlier in the day. At night, or after a bad night, use a 10-minute NSDR or yoga nidra script instead [1][2].
- Steer with your breath. Make exhales longer than inhales for calm, inhales longer for alertness, and keep them balanced (box breathing) to hold steady [1][2].
- Try the eye-roll test. Look up, then slowly close your eyes. If mostly the whites show, try a short self-hypnosis session (the Reveri app offers one- to two-minute refreshers) or see a clinician from the Society for Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis or the American Society of Clinical Hypnosis. If the iris shows, you may do better with mindfulness or other approaches [3].
- Use the floating-body screen for stress and night waking. Picture your body floating somewhere safe. Put the worry on an imaginary screen while your body stays comfortable, then think of one step you could take. If you wake at night, don't check the clock [3].
- Add a body scan. Move attention slowly from head to toe, breathing into each area and releasing tension. It is especially useful when cravings or stress lock onto something outside you [4].
- Test a high-arousal option too. If calm practices don't take, try a hard workout, a brisk walk or a supervised breathwork method. Epel found stress fell in every group of her trial, and Wim Hof breathing alone raised daily positive emotion [4]. Keep whichever you'll actually repeat.
Sources
- How Meditation Works & Science-Based Effective Meditations · Huberman Lab
- LIVE EVENT Q&A: Dr. Andrew Huberman Question & Answer in New York, NY · Huberman Lab
- Dr. David Spiegel: Using Hypnosis to Enhance Health & Performance · Huberman Lab
- Dr. Elissa Epel: Control Stress for Healthy Eating, Metabolism & Aging · Huberman Lab
Products and resources from this insight
Some of these are affiliate links: if you buy through them, Perfect Summary is paid a commission, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Perfect Summary earns from qualifying purchases.
-
Altered Traits · Daniel Goleman and Richard Davidson(our summary)Huberman highly recommends it on state versus trait changes from meditation.
-
Waking Up · Sam HarrisMeditation app that gave Huberman his most consistent practice.
-
Wherever You Go, There You Are · Jon Kabat-Zinn(our summary)The meditation book Huberman was given in high school.
-
Jaws: The Story of a Hidden Epidemic · Sandra Kahn and Paul Ehrlich(our summary)Cited as the evidence behind breathing through the nose rather than the mouth.
-
Reveri · David SpiegelSelf-hypnosis app built on Spiegel's Stanford research for stress, sleep, pain and habits.
-
The Telomere Effect · Elissa Epel(our summary)Epel's earlier book on stress, lifestyle and cellular aging





