Insight | Warmth and Competence, Clearly Signaled: How to Make a Strong First Impression
Vanessa Van Edwards says charisma is warmth and competence shown together, and that capable people get overlooked when they fail to signal either one. Oz Pearlman, Terrence J and former Secret Service agent Evy Poumpouras describe the signals that carry it in the first seconds, from the approach and eye contact to names and voice, and they are frank about what such cues cannot prove.
A strong first impression comes from signaling warmth and competence together, through behavior that can be practiced. Behavioral researcher Vanessa Van Edwards says people ask two things about anyone new: "Can I trust you and can I rely on you?" Warmth answers the first and competence the second, and she does not rank one ahead of the other.
Her finding is that most people who come across badly have both qualities and signal neither. If you are not signaling them, she says, people do not believe it. Her fixes are physical. Keep space between your earlobes and shoulders and between your torso and arms, because hunching signals danger to your own brain and weakens the voice. Keep your hands visible, speak at the low end of your natural range, and show people you like them. She cites a study of high school students in which the most-liked students were the ones who liked the most people and showed it. Neither warmth nor competence can be faked for long, and the aim is to be easy to talk to, not impressive.
Mentalist Oz Pearlman covers the first ten seconds. As a teenage magician approaching restaurant tables, he learned that strangers silently ask who you are and what you want, so he settled those questions quickly, approached at an angle, set a 30 second limit and opened with a question nobody refuses. He says an opening only earns a chance to deliver. For names his steps are listen, repeat, reply, because most forgotten names were never taken in.
Host Terrence J relies on homework about the people he will meet, common ground, the tone of his voice and an icebreaker. He will not attempt a name he cannot pronounce, and his hardest lesson was to stop trying to please everybody.
Evy Poumpouras, a former Secret Service agent and polygraph examiner, adds deliberate eye contact, facing people squarely, and an unhurried, deeper voice with pauses. She works from a few bullet points and never a script.
They differ mostly because of setting. Pearlman approached at an angle because he was a stranger interrupting a meal, while Poumpouras praises a straight approach between people who have agreed to talk. Van Edwards teaches engaging cues, yet Poumpouras says the person working hardest to charm is the one to watch. The article squares this through Van Edwards's own point that cues are for showing qualities you have. Pearlman spent months on one opening line and Poumpouras refuses to memorize, though she is talking about speaking at length. Van Edwards tries to be the first to like everyone, while Terrence J calls trying to be loved by everyone a trap. And Van Edwards reads body language with confidence, where Poumpouras says the research goes back and forth: "It's true and it's not true."
Poumpouras adds that not everyone sends cues the same way, and says never to call people out on what you notice.
What to do with it: before you walk in, open your posture and keep your hands where they can be seen. Do the homework. Come in at an angle with a short time limit if you are interrupting, and face the person squarely once you are talking. Say who you are and why you are there. Hold eye contact on purpose, including while they speak. Get the name and tie it to something. Show that you like them. Lower and slow your voice, bring a few points and not a script, match their energy and leave them wanting more. Go in to accomplish something, not to be approved of.





